Reviews for Cardhu 12 Year Old
Too Commercial We All Familiar
It is a very commercial, easy-drinking scotch. Bought it on sale for $59.99 CAD so no complain.
Peach, honey, heather, peanuts, wood (oak/sherry); weak finishing; no smoke, no peat.
If I were a newbie, I would give this a 5-star (and it still deserve a 4 star from a veteran)
After some years in scotch, I would say this doesn't do it for me anymore (just like the Highland Park 12 yr).
There are better value-options e.g. JW Black Label 1.75L always on sale before Christmas, or more exciting prospects Balvenie Caribbean Cask 14 yr, Auchentoshan Valinch, Nikka from the Barrel etc...
To me, I felt like drinking another scotch from the old man's cabinet which the taste we are all too familiar.
Master of Malt Customer Jul 3, 2017
It's fine, but not that interesting
Quite nice, but a bit too sweet for my taste. Very dominant honey and malt. Not very complex.
Emil Thuesen Jun 18, 2017
So good, Try it. If you don't like it , please send the remainder to me.
This was recommended by an old friend, who was responsible for my taste for Scotch. I like gentle single malts, just a whisp of smoke, or peat. over the years I have tried a load of brands, ages, distillery locations, etc. I find that aging, price, brand, distillery locations don't matter, its whats in my glass and mouth. I have enjoyed Glenlivet and Glenfiddick, especially their reserves and 15 year olds. I do have to say that my daily goto is Islay Mist. Very inexpensive and surprisingly pleasant, especially for an 8 year. But when I have the extra $$, Cardhu will be getting it.
Jimmy Bowden Mar 31, 2017
Mr Amrit Sen
Very Smooth for a single malt. Wonderful drink with nice after taste. I feel it is the best single malt I have ever tasted.
Amrit Sen Nov 2, 2016
Favorite Scotch. Not to mention being unbeatable for the money.
Even after receiving a pretty extensive education in Scotch I never found one I felt like having more than a single shot of. They were nice and I appreciated them very much but none of them ever struck me as something I wanted to drink over the course of an entire evening. The first time I sat with my Scotch educator and a bottle of Cardhu it was gone in a few hours - hitting it straight up.
After every sip my mouth just seems to want to have another. As a result, it's really hard for me to keep a bottle of this around.
Master of Malt Customer Oct 4, 2016