Teeling Small Batch Whiskey

I last reviewed this when I bought a bottle of Teeling Small Batch, 21st June 2022. Now, it must depend on the batch and which Rum Cask it gets to mature in, because last year I said it was harsh and the Rum overpowered the Whiskey. However, I thought I would give it another try (as it was reduced in a Flash Sale) and this bottle was completely different. It tastes lovely, with a hint of Rum coming through. As I said last year I like Rum and I like Whiskey, and with just a hint of Rum coming through this Whiskey is no longer harsh and tastes delightful.

Smells like Kahlua, tastes not like whiskey at all.
Creamy, sweet, floral, weird.
Nothing like any Irish whiskey I've ever had before.
Glad I had a shot in the pub, rather than a bottle.

Normally I am a big fan of Irish Whiskeys but this one is a no for me. The " notes " of rum punches you straight in the nose and mouth. A harsh finish and not smooth at all.

Quite enjoyable. Rum tones not overpowering.

This was a funny one for me. Since I’ve embarked on my whisky journey I’ve tried many and although I obviously have my preferences, I’ve essentially liked all I’ve tried to varying degrees. However this on opening and trying was the first time I actually didn’t like a whisky. I even contemplated throwing it away (which would have been annoying since I bought it in duty free so it’s a full ltr)… I gave it a few more chances and it definitely improved with each try. I have no idea why but maybe oxidation helped? Now it’s actually a pretty pleasant Irish whiskey. 0.5 stars for the initial experience, 3.5 stars now, balanced to a 3 stars total for me.

Good solid Irish Whiskey

i think this is quite poorly made, too spicy and lacks any character. smells like kerosene too.

Tastes unbalanced and over-spicy. Too sweet and the rum is too much in the foreground.

deliciously creamy, spicy and rich Irish blend.

Now, I like Rum and I like Whisky, but to my taste, being matured in a Rum cask has given this lovely Irish Whiskey a harsh Rum after taste, which spoils the smoothness of the Whiskey.