Trade
There is no single ultimate dram. The best American whiskeys range from sweet sippin’ bourbons to muscular ryes for wrestling vermouth in a Manhattan.
So, instead of pretending one bottle rules them all, we’ve picked some of the best American whiskeys for different tastes, budgets and classic cocktails.
Expect familiar American whiskey brands, less familiar styles and plenty of good reasons to make room on the shelf.
The best American whiskeys to try
Best all-round bourbon: Buffalo Trace
If somebody asks for a good bourbon whiskey without providing a dossier of preferences, Buffalo Trace is a sound place to begin. It is approachable, versatile and remarkably affordable, with enough flavour for sipping but no objection to being introduced to bitters, vermouth or ginger ale.
The flagship bourbon is made from corn, rye and malted barley, then matured in new oak barrels in the distillery’s old warehouses. It is batched from no more than 40 barrels at a time.
What does it taste like?
Caramel, creamy toffee, cinnamon, brown sugar, custard, espresso beans, toasted oak and chocolate-covered raisins.
Drink it: Neat, in a Whiskey Sour or as the dependable bourbon in your home bar.
Best balanced bourbon: Four Roses Small Batch Bourbon
Four Roses does things differently. The Kentucky distillery makes whiskey using two mash bills and five yeast strains, creating ten distinct bourbon recipes. Four of those recipes are brought together for Small Batch, producing a bourbon with sweetness, fruit, oak and spice all pulling in roughly the same direction.
It is richer than the standard Four Roses Bourbon, but remains approachable enough for newcomers. If you have a bit of a sweet tooth but don’t want to feel like you’ve licked the inside of a syrup tin, this is a very good call.
What does it taste like?
Manuka honey, buttered toast, winter spice, crème anglaise, dried flowers, ripe fruit and toasted oak.
Drink it: Neat after dinner or in an Old Fashioned with orange bitters.
Best wheated bourbon: W.L. Weller Special Reserve
William Larue Weller is a classic name in the wheat world. For this price, you’re getting a lot of heritage and class in one bottle.
Presented at 45% ABV, it’s mellow but not without backbone, boasting a wonderful balance of vanilla, savoury nuts, caramel and a small touch of spice on the finish.
What does it taste like?
Floral vanilla, honeysuckle, and creamy caramel backed by hints of fresh peach and mellow oaken spice.
Drink it: Try this in a Whisky Sour. It’s delicate, but potent.
Best sipping bourbon: Michter’s US*1 Bourbon or Leiper’s Fork Bottled in Bond Bourbon
I really struggled to pick one for this. So have two!
Michter’s US*1 Bourbon is produced in small batches, typically comprising no more than two dozen barrels. Small batch does not automatically make a whiskey better, despite what several thousand labels would have you believe, but Michter’s backs up the claim with an impressively layered dram.
What does the Michter’s taste like?
Buttery caramel, vanilla, milk chocolate, peach, apricot, nutmeg, honeyed almonds, pepper and sweet oak char.
Leiper’s Fork in Tennessee, meanwhile, uses five years ageing, a hearty 50% ABV, and a good balance of wheat and malted barley in its mashbill to create a rich and robust profile packed with notes of butterscotch, maple, dried citrus, and sweet herbs.
What does the Leiper’s Fork taste like?
Silky soft layers of butterscotch, backed by sweet herbs, dried orange peels, and some boozy red fruit.
Drink it: Neat, slowly. Take your time. Preferably get both and compare and contrast.
Best whiskey for a Manhattan: Brother’s Bond American Blended Rye Whiskey
We’ve got a new answer when somebody asks for the best rye whiskey for a Manhattan. Bottled at 95 proof, or 47.5%% ABV in sensible money, it has the weight and spice to stand up to sweet vermouth without disappearing into it.
Why “blended rye”? Further reading can be found here, but the cliff notes are this: 4 different mash bills, one super high rye, the other three are beneath 51% but above 20%. A unique product in a crowded market that stands up for itself in many a serve.
What does it taste like?
Sweet candied fruit intensity, hints of ripe pineapple, with waves of creamy vanilla, cinnamon sugar and a smidge of After Eight.
Drink it: In a Manhattan. We really could not have made that clearer.
Most underrated American whiskey: Mellow Corn
The lurid yellow label puts people off, but Mellow Corn has built a devoted following for good reason.
Made at Heaven Hill, this straight corn whiskey contains at least 80% corn and is matured in used oak rather than the new, charred barrels required for bourbon. That allows the buttery cereal character to remain front and centre. At 50% ABV, it is also considerably more serious than its bargain-bin tailoring suggests.
What does it taste like?
Buttered corn, toffee popcorn, vanilla, brown sugar, oak and woody spice.
Drink it: Neat, in a Highball or wherever you might otherwise use bourbon.
Best American whiskey curveball: Kings County Peated Bourbon
When Kings County initially launched this, there were no other peated bourbons. At least that we can think of.
The hybrid whiskey is not just a pioneer, it’s genuinely delicious. It has a BBQ profile that feels incredibly U-S-A! Ideal for 4 July celebrations.
What does it taste like?
Smoked brisket, coffee cake, and stem ginger join the aforementioned aromas.
Drink it: Add soda for a smoky Highball that will refresh you nicely in this heatwave.
Best new American whiskey: Star Hill Farm 2026 Release
I won’t go too deep into this one, because I already have, just understand that this is some of the best American whiskey on the market right now. Get it before it’s gone.
What does it taste like?
Dark and dense with notes of molasses, fig, and delicate spice.
Drink it: Neat. Another one to take your time with.
Best American single malt whiskey: Courage & Conviction Signature Malt
Virginia Distillery Co.’s Courage & Conviction range is at the forefront of the American single malt whisky revolution. And it deserves to be.
The signature expression is made from 100% North American malted barley, long fermented with a two-strain proprietary yeast mixture (one for yield, one for flavour), fermented for a generous 72 hours, the whisky matured for at least six years in a host of sherry casks, bourbon barrels, and STR European red wine casks. How good does that sound? It tastes better.
What does it taste like?
Laden with layers of milk chocolate, toasted pecans, and honeyed stone fruits.
Drink it: Neat, next to single malt from Scotland, Ireland etc. To understand what all the fuss is about.
Best old American whiskey: American Bourbon 10 Year Old (That Boutique-y Whisky Company)
Representing great value at its old age is this bourbon from That Boutique-y Whisky Company’s core range.
It was distilled from a classic corn-forward mash bill (77% corn) and aged in deeply charred American oak barrels for a full decade. That’s a long time in the bourbon game. But it’s worth the wait.
What does it taste like?
Rich layers of toffee, ginger, and tropical fruits, backed by oily nuts, oak char, pepper, and a hint of leather.
Drink it: Neat, or in a decadent Old Fashioned.
What is American whiskey?
America gave the world the electric guitar, Bill Nye the Science Guy and spray-on cheese. It also gave us bourbon, rye, Tennessee whiskey and an increasingly adventurous cast of distillers working with everything from blue corn to American single malt.
American whiskey covers several legally defined styles. The grains used, the proportion of each grain in the mash bill and the type of oak all help determine what ends up in your glass.
Bourbon must be made in the United States from a mash containing at least 51% corn. It is distilled to no more than 80% ABV and matured in new, charred oak barrels, entering the cask at no more than 62.5% ABV. Contrary to one particularly persistent myth, bourbon does not have to come from Kentucky.
Rye whiskey follows similar production rules, but its mash must contain at least 51% rye. That usually brings more pepper, herbs and dry spice than you would find in a typical bourbon.
Corn whiskey must contain at least 80% corn. Unlike bourbon and rye, it does not have to be matured. If it does see wood, it generally goes into used or uncharred new oak.
Tennessee whiskey is made in Tennessee and typically undergoes the Lincoln County Process, in which the spirit is filtered through sugar maple charcoal. This can soften the texture without removing all that lovely corn, vanilla and oak character.
Then there are wheat whiskeys, malt whiskeys, blends and the newly recognised American single malt whiskey category. Bourbon may command the most shelf space, but it is only one state in a much larger union.
Five classic American whiskey cocktails
The United States has contributed rather more to cocktail culture than lurid shots and drinks served in buckets. These iconic American drinks should cover most bottles in your cabinet:
- Old Fashioned: Bourbon or rye, sugar, bitters and citrus oils.
- Manhattan: Rye or bourbon, sweet vermouth and bitters.
- Whiskey Sour: Whiskey, lemon juice and sugar, optionally shaken with egg white.
- Sazerac: Rye whiskey, sugar, Peychaud’s bitters and an absinthe rinse.
- Boulevardier: Bourbon or rye with sweet vermouth and bitter Italian aperitivo.
If you are buying one bottle for cocktails, choose something bottled at 45% ABV or above. Ice, sugar, citrus and vermouth can bully a delicate whiskey rather efficiently.
Which American whiskey should you choose?
The best American whiskey is ultimately the one that suits how you drink. Fortunately, testing that theory is considerably more enjoyable than it sounds
