Reviews for Talisker 10 Year Old
Better Taliskers out there
Smells wonderfully sweet on an initial nose (I immediately thought of cider) and with a lovely smoke, but simply too tough on the palate. It's a little too strong for my liking despite the relatively modest alcohol content, so one for some watering down. Completely agree with the above comments about a medicinal/chemical quality. Aftertaste is pretty smooth but not enough going on generally - I'm really confused by all the rave reviews. I'm off to tuck into the Distiller's Edition.
Master of Malt Customer Nov 11, 2013
Amazing elixir
Best whiskey I have ever had.
Master of Malt Customer Nov 8, 2013
Awful!!
The smoked element to this whisky is absolutely foul. I can't help but think something has gone seriously wrong as it just tastes of burnt plastic. i forced down a measure telling myself it would get better but quite frankly it made me feel ill. I cannot fathom how people can enjoy this whisky and can only assume that the good reviews are marketing plants!!!
Master of Malt Customer Oct 27, 2013
Not a rookie's gamble, but a prize to real men who can handle it.
Peat-forward whiskies, such as Laphroaig, Lagavulin, Talisker, etc., are not for the faint hearted. It is a classic whisky in every right, and is what a whisky should be. Right now, floral/sweet/light, and boutique bottlings of fragrant multi-wood casks are all the rave because they're feminine, and dessert like. Cragganmore, Talisker, Oban, Lagavulin, Glenkinchie, and Dalwhinnie are the "classics". They are meant to warm you up on a cold scottish night. The smokiness makes it pair exceptionally well with food. And it is fairly complex despite being 10 years old, although peaty whiskies are best young. If you hate this, stay away from Islay whiskies, if you want to like it... start drinking blended scotch instead of feminine perfume bottlings. I didn't taste a big medicinal/bandage rubber saltiness out of Talisker as much as Laphroaig, and Lagavulin was saltier and less smoky. Anyway, it's not the whisky, it's the drinker.
Master of Malt Customer Oct 26, 2013
first island dram
Smokey rather than peaty to me. Very enjoyable would buy again.
Master of Malt Customer Oct 25, 2013