Lagavulin 16 Year Old

I you like the ubiquitous Islay profile o peat, smoke, and sweet nectar this is the bottle you need in your cabinet. Only negative is the price keeps going up.

17th February 2020

Just finished the bottle I brought home for Christmas. Lovely, a full, peaty flavour and enough depth to make me pause and think after every mouthful. Going onto my favourites list without a shadow of doubt

17th February 2020

My first taste of this alarmingly excellent whisky was when I made a film about it back in the 1970's. Then it had a smoothness and a magical smoky peat aroma that no others possessed. That has become less intense since the days of its ownership by Distillers Co. But for my money (now more than double the price it was then) it is the best malt around.

10th February 2020

Still the King of the Islay single malts. I have tried most of them and always compare them to this gem of a dram.. Up there with the best in class...

25th January 2020

I am fully aware that I will get some hate for this review but I find the Lagavulin 16 to be the most overrated whiskey in the market! It’s peaty notes taste artificial and mask over any flavour whiskey. I feel as though because this whiskey is popular everyone has jumped on the bandwagon an automatically believes that it is a good whiskey. Long live Balvenie!

24th January 2020

Wonderful dram! Had to get another bottle!

11th January 2020

An Islay gem with a delcious and well balanced combination of peat, smoke and savory notes on the nose and palete.

7th January 2020

World class, big hitter, in every aspect,simply brilliant,,, the Kenny Dalglish of whiskeys,,, 👍 😁

5th January 2020

Simply brilliant, the best of all the Islay single malt whiskys,, full of smoke and charcoal flavours,, great tasting at all levels,,,

5th January 2020

Simply the finest Islay has to offer, it smells wonderful with the not so subtle smoky aroma from the bottle and tastes better. I find a splash of water helps you appreciate the flavour. Probably not the whisky for an introduction to smoky / peaty malts but never forgotten once tried. My favourite whisky of any region

1st January 2020

My girlfriend got me another bottle of Lag for Christmas. This just edges Ardbeg Uigeadail as my favourite single malt. I never tire of it! It's absolutely superb, such a lovely vanilla finish to it, it makes the long Scottish Winter evenings almost something to look forward to!

25th December 2019

I never had the privilege of trying "old" Lagavulin, however, against current affordable everyday Islay whisky such as Laphroaig 10, Ardbeg etc, I can't help but rate Lagavulin 16 ahead of them, it's just an exquisite single malt that is well worth the price.

While my dram of choice is Laphroaig 10 cask strength, if it happens to be unavailable at a sensible price, I would wholly recommend Lagavulin 16, and if that's not available then Ardbeg 10. Ardbeg 10 packs more punch but Lagavulin truly is a multi-layered gem of a scotch that reacts well to small amounts of water and you can play with all night.

25th December 2019

i’m a teetotaller, I am not a big fan of alcohol.. but.. This whisky can turns me to alcoholic. i can’t resist when i see it in front me.. like dangling a piece of chocolate in front of a child face. i like it to drink it anytime anywhere .. before i sleep, mid day and when i wake up in the morning .. Ohh you bloody lagavulin!

24th December 2019

Like an angel peeing on your tongue.

21st December 2019

Smoky sweet Islay gem. This whisky is an explosion of complex flavor that shows its maturity in nose and palette . Definitely my go to dram by the fire with a cubano sidemate.

12th December 2019

Delicious.

12th December 2019

Yes it’s got worse over the years, but it’s still a fine, fine whisky. More depth and character than other entry level Islay whisky. Very little smoke but more flavours. If I drink a laphroaig 10 I feel like a dirty, homeless, uneducated imbecile.... if I drink a lagavulin 16 I feel like an Earl of an English shire. Just more alcohol by volume please Diageo.

30th November 2019

Ive tried many a peated expression, and I love many of them. I thoroughly dislike Lagavulin. I feel like it has similar characteristics so other peated whiskies except it turns those positives to negatives. Iodine, but bitter and unpleasant; smoke, but quickly fades and lacks balance; liquorice aftertaste, just no. I realise I'm in the minority but I've been deeply unimpressed by this whisky I have heard so much about, and can think of many other peated expressions I'd reach for first. Perhaps I has a bad bottle? But I tasted nothing to make me come back for more.

26th November 2019

This is all you really need, forget the rest

20th November 2019

My daughter gave me a bottle Lagavulin 16 year old for my birthday,she knows I like a dram on the odd evening.

I have enjoyed other peat whiskys on occasion, but this 16year old is the best peaty whisky I have tasted.

On opening the bottle, a very pleasant peat aroma with a hint vanilla.

The initial taste is peaty but not unpleasant, rather warming, sweet and smooth, the taste hangs to the palate, there is a hint of salted caramel and fruit, peaty oak, all in all a truly sophisticated whisky.

In truth the best of the best, some people say some there is no bad whisky's only some better than others...this is one of the best...

I will always have a bottle of Lagavulin 16 year old now..

Many thank's Sarah-Jane...x

4th November 2019

Always a go to dram at my well stocked bar. Rarely disappoints with it's intense and complex nose and palete. Smokey and sweet with hints of mint in the finish. Delicious and reasonably priced for a 16 year old whisky.

4th November 2019

Lagavulin 16 used to be one of my desert island top 5 whiskies. However, I haven't had it for a while and the bottle I opened last evening left me feeling rather disappointed: never mind desert island - I wouldn't even take it on a day trip to Bute. Admittedly, recently I've been spending more time with 46% and cask strength ncf Campbeltown whiskies and Carn Mor editions so, perhaps, the Lagavulin seemed a bit tame by comparison but the peat and sea spray attack seemed rather muted and the salty dryness in the finish wasn't as expected. Don't get me wrong, this is still a very good dram and at under £50 better value that several other 15/16 year old malts but maybe it's being left behind a bit in its 43% and chill-filtered state.

26th October 2019

It’s reminiscent of those teenage parties when you sculled for lager the morning after and swigged from a half crushed can of hoffmeister that someone had used as an ashtray. Add a swig of TCP from your mums medicine cabinet and there you have it ...Lagavulin 16 - just delicious

23rd October 2019

Still a phenomenal Whisky despite Diageo's best efforts to conventionalize its taste.

10th October 2019

A proper drop of Islay scotch. Rich, smokey and smooth. A definite mainstay on my top shelf.

28th September 2019

Smoky but very nice!

22nd September 2019

All i taste is smoke

21st September 2019

Intense deep caramel sweet and peaty nose, smoky with liquorice notes, long dry spicy finish,

10th September 2019

Bought it yesterday. What have you done to Lagavulin?!! Now it's like cheap vodka with added liquid smoke! Very harsh! Yes it's without paper seal (bottled 16 jan 19)

7th September 2019

Very nice whisky, smokey apple notes with a long sweet finish.

25th August 2019

I am surprised to say I like the Lagavulin 16, so smokey and slightly rough, luckily I like it rough. No water needed, notes of crisp apple, vanilla undertones and finishes with a sweet salted caramel aftertaste... just exquisite!

23rd August 2019

Best Islay whisky.My favourite of all time

17th August 2019

I wasn’t ready for the smokiness but was quite impressed over time. The smoothness and mellow aftertaste is sweet perfection. Sadly I can’t go 5 stars because I tried it in the wrong setting. But knowing what I know now I’d find the perfect snack to go with. It might also be my phobia of liquid smoke in food or sauces. But very impressive and belongs in the cabinet for sure

16th August 2019

The long spicy finish is great! I'm just a begginner and I really like smoky and "corsé" brevage. This one did impress me for my first Islay malt! 9/10

10th August 2019

This Islay beauty is an exceptional balance of sweet and savory notes. The nose is met with a woody char with dried fruits and a hint of mint. The palate has a delicious BBQ brisket flavor with caramelized brown sugar, phenols and sweet almonds ion the back.

3rd August 2019

From Australia.
When the Lagavulin was imported from Islay with the little "Property of the Distillery" paper seal it was a magnificent dram. Sadly since the paper seal disappeared the quality has dropped as well . Nobody has owned up to this, why?

3rd August 2019

A whisky that is delicious and characterized by well balanced flavor or peat, smoke, dried fruits, salted toffee and coastal wafts of seaweed and shoreline breeze. Pairing this with brisket, double smokedy cheese and red grapes is heaven only to be complimented by a Cubano at the end . Cheers.

29th July 2019

Liquid gold with a momentous palate and lasting finish. Well balanced notes of peat, smoke, dried fruit and oaky salted toffee in the back. Paired with BBQ brisket, smoky cheese and red grapes can only be beaten by a nice Cubano to follow. Magnificent !

29th July 2019

This is how all whisky should be, very elegant, classic and luxurious, very satisfying sipping whisky, very suitable for fathers like me!

29th July 2019

Tastes like industrial cleaner.

18th July 2019

I tried my very first Lagavulin 16, on Monday evening. What a wonderful dram!
Left it in the glass for a good 16 minutes, nosing continually. It is, without doubt, the most beautiful single malt I have ever had the pleasure to taste!
Wonderful.

26th June 2019

I was given a dram at a local bar and it was my first sampling of this single malt whisky. Needless to say it was love at first nose and taste. Who cares if a little coloring is added or it is chill filtered??? The taste blows those considerations away. If you can make a whisky this good by adding those ingredients then please Sir I want more .... brilliant Diageo !

26th June 2019

Hmmm...ok. The positives. It’s a nice dram. Smokey, dried fruits with a hint of salt. Worth a try.

Negatives? Well. I just wish Diageo were as good at making a quality whisky as they are at marketing it. Getting someone as cool and manly as Ron Swanson to endorse your product is a stroke of genius because that’s all this dram has over other islays.

It’s over priced! £49 in the UK. Packed with E150 which is strange as you would have thought that a 16 year old would have obtained enough colour from the barrels. It’s chill filtered which I’m sure is fine for those who like adding ice in their whisky.

Theirs better whiskies out there and better Islay’s. Ardbeg is a better drink. No chill filtered no E150. (It’s a pretty pale colour) I find it more smokey and more complex.

In short: it’s a nice dram, but it’s time to try something different and something better! Forget the marketing, it’s time to tell Diageo to get Lagavulin back to the better quality whisky it used to be.

22nd June 2019

Such an exquisite blend of sophistication and romantic roughness that each mouthful practically takes your breath away.

20th June 2019

I just finished a bottle and I want to cry. I bought a Laphroig 10 as it was on special offer and it just doesn't cut the mustard, the smoke's there but not the rest of it, and the mouth-feel is pathetic by comparison. I'm not going to pretend I'm some whisky buff, I can't tell you what it is about this that I love so much about this whisky, but it's pretty much perfect for me.

19th June 2019

Probably my favorite whiskey ever and I’m normally a bourbon drinker. So weird and delicious.

18th June 2019

For a whisky that is chill filtered and color added, I still haven't found a better dram in the 16 year old range that is otherwise more impacting on nose and pallate. It is so well balanced with smoke and sweetness that you begin to salivate witha simple nosing. Would love to see this whisky at a higher abv for the money.

14th June 2019

Strong, smokey and peppery. Just the way Tony Stark and RDJ likes it. No wonder Tony chose this as the Scotch brand of his choice. I shared this with several friends of mine after endgame to celebrate 10 years of Avengers and the Infinity Saga and I can confess this is one hell of a scotch to toast to

7th June 2019

A lovely deep flavour that rolls all the way into the deep smoke that the nose promises.
An incredibly decent whisky to sink back with at the end of a long day, I'm not saving this for special occasions I am keeping this one close at hand.

4th June 2019

I like my scotch chilled with an ice ball, not fancy metal bearings. I feel the little water that gets to the scotch changes the flavor a touch. Without the ice I get more of the iodine sharpness, I’m fine with this. Pour it over an ice ball and it becomes a little something else. Still Smokey, very much so, but a mellow oak-ness that sits with the palate for a good while after the initial taste. It is my go to scotch. If you like a fine cigar or pipe without the doctor yelling at you, this scotch is for you.

1st June 2019

For Islay malt, I like Laphroaig much more. I feel that the Lag 16 is a bit sharp to the taste, and not what I remember from prior to the Diageo takeover.

23rd May 2019

I'm sorry, who puts No! and then basically insults everyone else as being an inexperienced drinker because of their 4/5 star reviews??? How RUDE! Love this whisky and have been drinking it for quite some time, couldn't really care less what others think, I've tasted a lot of whisky in my time, this is still my favourite. And if you prefer the taste of bells well then that's up to you...

9th May 2019

The only whisky I love, after an amazing initial introduction to lots of different whiskies in a pub in Inverliever 20+ years ago!

3rd May 2019

From the moment I tried it I knew this was the one. No need for over analysis.
I enjoy every sip and Diageo and e150 are the furthest thing from my mind.
Absolutely wonderful. If I could only drink one dram from now on this would be it.

29th April 2019

I feel the rating on this is from Diageo’s marketing and from inexperienced consumers. This is not an example of what a good Islay scotch has to offer. Overpriced, watered down, chill filtered, loads of e150 added, not very complex especially for a 16 year old. This has great potential but it’s not even close to where it should be. Fix the things listed above and put some quality and care into the spirit itself and it would be one of the best instead of trying to use marketing gimmicks to appeal and fool inexperienced drinkers. Diageo is much more worried about its profits than making a good product just like so many companies now a days and people aren’t educated enough to see it I guess.

22nd April 2019

A quiet crisp cool evening alone. Sitting on an old comfortable camping chair deep in the woods with a warm comfortable fire at hand. The smell of sweet smoke wafting near by ... So looking forward to the next.

21st April 2019

If you like Islay-type whiskeys, you will LOVE this scotch. It remains the standard to which other Islay whiskies are judged. Just buy it. You will not be disappointed.

20th April 2019

A huge whisky! Big smokey hit on the initial nose, gives way to medicinal iodine and vanilla.

Again, lots of smoke on the initial palate, with sherry, vanilla, dried fruits and some spice developing through the mid. Watch out for the big peaty, leathery kick on the back palate to finish!

Long finish, with the more subtle notes lingering: sherry, spices and vanilla; oaky sweetness develops at the last.

I do agree with those that think this whisky is a bit overrated, it lacks a certain subtlety and refinement of balance to my taste.

17th April 2019

It's good. Expected a bit more after the reviews. But it's good. Maybe a bit pricey.

15th April 2019

I feel half these reviews are from Diageos marketing abilities rather than the drink itself. E150, low abv, Slightly complex but nothing special, and a huge increase in price recently make this an ok dram at an extremely high price. This is good don’t get me wrong but that’s it good. As far as even close to the smokiest nose from an Islay that’s just plain not true. There are great drinks out there for this price. At least in my area I’ve seen it 80 usd on the low end and 130 at the top. It has a good flavor to it and is smooth but could really benefit from a higher abv but that means profit decreases for Diageo and as long as people who have not expanded their Islay horizons past this are flocking to the stuff it won’t change. But that’s who it’s made for I guess people who don’t mind the fake color, high prices, and a watered down dram. Anyway to they drink itself. Salty meats, dried fruit, peat smoke, cream. 85/100

4th April 2019

I love you, you sweet whiskey. Keep doing what you’re doing

2nd April 2019

My go to daily dram. Yes, an expensive habbit but you only live once. This gem is an inculcation of the spirit of Islay. The amazing nose and delicious palate make it a sensory experience. We can all use a little "me" time with something a memorable as Lagavulin 16. Cheers!

23rd March 2019

When I first tried laga 16 I was a little underwhelmed. I'd read so many reviews of it being 'the one' but it seemed just another Islay. Some iodine, some smoked kippers and the rest of the usual suspects for Hebridean whisky. Next to my Ledaig 18 it seemed a little one dimensional. I did however persist and keep returning to it. One magical night after a dram of a single barrelcask strength bourbon I came back to it. A few drops of water, 15 mins to open up and I took a sip. Suddenly it revealed itself to me in all its glory, the balance is just exceptional. It opens with a salvo of mellow smoke, followed by a flash of aniseed on the tongue before sherry and chocolate sit on top of a blustery western shore. It fades into the distance leaving smoked meats, chocolate and oak, finally dissipating to fennel seed on the back of the tongue. I don't know why it took me so long to fully appreciate its glory but it's a great, great whisky.

14th March 2019

Delicious on the nose and on the taste. Dried fruit, caramel, vanilla, bbq, sherried biscuits, peat. brine, savory, roasted almonds with baked apples, hit of mint and sweet and sour plum sauce and of cousre smoke.

9th March 2019

The title says it all. As a fan of peated whiskeys, there are 2 bottles I return to: the Lagavulin 16 on Fridays and better days and the Talisker Dark Storm on weekdays :-). Its a wonderfull whiskey, the aroma peated but not too agressive, woody and relaxing. The taste reflects the peatiness (as opposed to a Laphroaig where smell beats taste)
with some sea and leather in there. If you take the peated whiskey trip: start with a Talisker Skye, work your way up to Talisker 10, Dark Storm and finally a Lagavulin. Hope you will appreciate it as I did.

5th March 2019

This Scotch belongs in a place of honor. Delicious both on the nose and on the palate. The earthy notes and seaside brine meld nicely with a sweetness that lingers and finishes with the classic Islay conviction. The best value for a 16 year old anywhere !

4th March 2019

For me, the Laga 16 is a wonderful example of peat, iodine, age and balance. Very consistent, at least in the few years I have drank it. Not as “out-going” as the Ardbergs or Laphroiags but the balance and age always makes me sit back and think - oh yeah.

24th February 2019

Consistently unbelievable, my favourite single malt without question. Last bottle was slightly different to those in the past, possibly more salty / briney. Still remains my number one.
The flavour is true and comforting, earthy smoke with sweet brine. Good finish. Superb with a few drops of water.
I have never been disappointed.

17th February 2019

Intense... different... outstanding. On a scale of 1 to 10... a solid 8. This is the drink I buy when I have been through a serious whisky line up and I have had enough. It takes everything to a whole new level...smokiness...spice...heat...the whole load. My secret weapon during a whisky duel.

15th February 2019

Delicious infusion of earthy peat and bonfire aromas with a sweet sherried cask undertones. The finish is classic Islay, rich, longlasting and very well balalnced . A masterpiece.

11th February 2019

This is the first whiskey I've tried that goes down painlessly, leaving you to savor the deliciousness of its lasting, spice riddled flavor.

3rd February 2019

I can't say enough good things about this one. Its got it all...peat, smoke, oak and spice. Incredible nose, intense flavors that linger and a ton of bold character to boot. Put it on your list. You will not be disappointed.

18th January 2019

Always bought whiskies based on what’s on offer at Tesco, but decided....yes, after Parks and Rec, to treat myself to Lagavulin. Do I like it? Yes! The nose is smoky with spice and a hint of vanilla. The taste is nothing like I’ve tried before. Definitely the smokiest dram but not as iodine ridden as Laphroaig. It’s got an earthy taste and a dryness that I’ve not had in even other Islay’s. It is a lovely whisky, but it’s either your taste or not. For me it’s a unique and one I’ll be coming back to.

13th January 2019

This is a great Scotch one must have this in your house at all times

13th January 2019

Came back to this laga after couple month drinking others islay, highland whiskys, as well as japanese and even Indian (Amrut). I may have tried 50 different bottles. You can have it at 55 chf here in Switzerland, sometimes for less than 50 chf and for this price, it is a GIFT ! Men this is good... It is like Japanese Blend's top quality dram mixed with the best smoky taste I ever had. I think I should go there, in Scotland, tell the guys from Laga how perfect this whisky is... Bravo les gars !

9th January 2019

So I got this for the Xmas period. Never tried it before and have to say I did enjoy it. It reminds me of a whisky for the more experienced who enjoy a smoker flavour. However I'm still fairly new to the market and enjoyed this so if your debating then give it a go for sure.

5th January 2019

Rich? Yes. Dry? No! I find a hint of honey in this Scotch. It makes me wonder if it spent a little time in an oloroso sherry cask.
As for smokiness, I liked the comparison to Lapsang Souchong, of which Islay malts have always reminded me. Both the tea and the scotch can wonderfully take the edge off a winter afternoon.

1st January 2019

To the 1-star man on 28th February 2018...when you hated your bottle and threw it out, did you by chance just leave in the bottle and leave the bottle in a clean bag or bin somewhere, and would that bottle still be in your possession? If so, I have a warm home for the "burnt forest fire" you disliked so much: my waiting maw.

My catch-phrase used to be, "I don't drink scotch, but when I do, it has heather honey, saffron and spices in it." Then I tried Laphroaig, and I liked it very much. Then I got stuck out of town with nothing to do but watch Netflix, and picked Parks and Rec. Then I tried Lagavulin. Now, when I talk about Lagavulin, I only use a Nick Offerman accent. It's that good. I have Ardbeg 10, and was just gifted another bottle, but I'm afraid it will be exchanged for my first owned bottle of 16. Cheers to those who enjoy the king of scotch!

26th December 2018

Just stop reading this a pour yourself a generous dram. Keep it in your mouth for 20 seconds and fly away.

24th December 2018

I've had a bottle of 16 year Lagavulin, for 4 years now, and it's never been opened,the last time I drank it and I had a few, was in 1997 and the memory of it has stayed with me for these past 21 years,... I will think about opening it soon,

20th December 2018

I do believe chill filtering takes the soul out of the liquid. Glenlivet and Glenfiddich chill filter the hell out of their bland whisky and there's nothing there. This however I don't know what it is but nothing compares to it or comes close the balance of peat sherry fruit and grain has a finesse I have never experienced in any other whisky and as I make my way through my 3rd bottle of this in the past few months I have to say I haven't had anything better in a couple hundred I've tried.

14th December 2018

My partner's go-to whisky, and her favourite Islay malt.

13th December 2018

I'm either missing something, got a bad batch or this bottle does not hold up to the competition (i.e. my ardbeg uigeadail). Comparing the 2, I find the Laga 16 lacking in flavour, I honestly don't get the hype. I really wanted to like this and bought it due to the strong recommendations.

It delivers in peat, but the rest, I feel I find it under-powered compared to my Ardbeg Uigeadail, which I find far more enjoyable.

11th December 2018

Purchased this last Christmas for a gift, it arrived extremely well packaged. You have to fold the box up yourself -which is a good idea as then it keeps it immaculate. Delicious whisky to enjoy.

5th December 2018

My favorite was Laphroaig 10 for the longest time, until I had this. I also love Ardbeg 10.

I feel Laphroaig leans on a deeper tar aroma. Ardbeg on a super well balanced smoky smooth dram.

Lagavulin on the other hand incorporates both of these splendidly as a base, then adds a top notch oak, spice and roast that just takes you home.

5th December 2018

A fantastic, peaty masterpiece. Addictive.

28th November 2018

It's worth way more than bargain barrel prices don't give it away for crying out loud. Ninety bucks

24th November 2018

Very Nice

16th November 2018

Possibly the best value for money single malt: £44 (duty free) for a 16 y/o is commendable. I would buy again, certainly when compared to the NAS offerings from the other island distilleries.

HOWEVER the colour is faked with caramel, it has been chill-filtered so the flavour is diminished. Shame. To my mind it isn't as good as it used to be, (2018) the Lag16 seems 'smoother' and has less Islay character.

To the palate, this starts off very well: smoke, peat and rounded rich sherry character. The finish becomes harsher with some faults. I imagine this will please the shills who like to use the word 'go-to'.

7th November 2018

A mans whisky. Imagine you've boiled an old work-horses harness for several days. My favourite for many years.

4th November 2018

Been my go-to single malt for over 20 years. Just got gifted a new bottle from a neighbour who also appreciates the Islay. He is now my favourite neighbour!

1st November 2018

My go to Scotch, the smokey flavor is outstanding, and the peat isn't overpowering. A wonderful whisky to sip, although it can start tasting a little too good so make sure to limit yourself!

27th October 2018

I have tried couple other islay whisky and I find this one to be very balance and more subtile than the others (in the same price range). You have the peat, the frutiness and also a long finished. Reminds me of the Laphroaig 10yo kind of taste... Not only peat but some sweetness and character.
I have also tried the 2000 Distiller Edition, which for me is the best whisky so fare I have ever had. It taste quiet the same, the DE has more complexity and is more on the honey and vanilla where de 16yo is more on fresh fruits like lemon and orange. In the end : very good but not perfect.

25th October 2018

An absolute delight !

22nd October 2018

This is my favorite Scotch at the moment. My sister turned me on to the Islay versions a few years ago, and after many sampling’s, this is the one I continue to return to. Strong, but not over powering. Smooth, but not easy drinking. Simply perfect with a cut of steak and a buttered baked potato.

18th October 2018

Its a great tasting whisky. Goes down smoothly over the course of an evening especially with good friends

12th October 2018

Love it, very unique taste

6th October 2018

Probabily, one of the better malt of Scotland. Superb. Peaty but with full body

30th September 2018

This is the kind if whisky I stop drinking once my bottle is half empty and only enjoy again once I have a back up replacement. The thought of having to go thru life without a Lagavulin 16 on my whisky shelf is just to scary.

26th September 2018

too much for me at this time...prefer Glenfiddich, Oban, Glenkichie etc.

24th September 2018

Earthy, rich & smoky. Simply the best!

15th September 2018

Peat smoke and iodine rise from the glass. Upon sipping, I first noticed the astringency, often compared to a good tea, then the massive malt backbone asserted itself. Despite its age the cask does not dominate the flavor. The peat smoke, iodine, malt, and cask all assert themselves then leave behind the iodine and a bit of phenolic resin, but not nearly as much as Laphroaig.

14th September 2018

I replaced water in my daily intake of liquids with this one.

8th September 2018

A very peculiar taste. The aroma and the flavour had me on a bit of a quest. An adventurous quest.

2nd September 2018

My wife bought me a bottle for Christmas, she has regretted it ever since, I have not. :)

25th August 2018

My to go whiskey.

Ron Swanson.

19th August 2018

Always the best

19th August 2018

Absolutely delightful. You can tell this scotch has historic experience behind it.

18th August 2018

I never knew I liked Scotch until I tried this. Smoke, vanilla, cherry, and... did I mention smoke?

9th August 2018

Simply stunning. I get lots of mellow peppery cigar smoke and a sweetness that borders on wine gums! One of the nicest I have ever tasted and definitely the best of the Islays.

8th August 2018

I appreciate all the regions and their expressions but no other whisky comes close for me. Sitting in front of the fire with my dog after a day in Scottish mountains, 2 glasses in to a dusty Laga 16. Can't get much better. Ignore the low star reviews bemoaning too smoky or peaty. This is not a dram for some palates. That said, you can't fairly criticise an Islay for having the characteristics of an Islay in the same way you can't criticise a cat for not being a dog (as it were). If you appreciate Islay whisky, know what you are buying and have half an idea what to expect, then you can do no wrong here... beats excellent Ardbeg and Laphroaig equivalents....King to the Islay princes.

6th August 2018

All my life I’ve avoided Europe and it’s multitudes of terribleness, but it turns out, much to my surprise there is actually one place in Europe that is worth seeing. These tiny islands off the coast of Scotland where God’s chosen elixirs are distilled, barrelled and prepared for consumption. This is worth the trip.”

4th August 2018

This is my favourite scotch. I also like the distillers editions.

3rd August 2018

The one that made me an whisky enthusiast. Absolute classic!

29th July 2018

I have spent 20 years and a lot of money trying to find a better whisky. I give up!

28th July 2018

Every time I try to branch out and try another whisky, I just end up being disappointed it's not Lagavulin 16.

19th July 2018

I’ve wanted to try this for a while but always opted for a slightly cheaper Laphroaig or Bowmore. I got a bottle for my 40th though and it is beautiful!

I’m not too techy with the descriptors (a whiff of vanilla, a hint of old boot leather etc.) But if you love the peatiness of Islay whisky then this has it in spades. It’s as peaty as Laphroaig 10 but mellower at the same time.

My favourite scotch by a long way!

14th July 2018

If you like a peaty whisky this should absolutely be in your glass.

12th July 2018

I made a pledge to review every whisky I drink to educate the world about the finer points of whisky (he said optimistically). But this review is a total waste of time as all of us already know; LV 16 is a masterclass in smoky, peatiness infused with sea air and seaweed, yet perfectly mixed with a good slug of your granny's sweet and sumptuous cream sherry. An absolute must have classic. I'll stop wasting my time now!

10th July 2018

As a devoted fan of Islay malts, Lagavulin 16 is the standard to which all others are compared. An absolute "must have" in a malt whiskey lover's cabinet. A sublime marriage of carefully controlled peatiness and smoke with an aged complexity that is unmatched by other Islay malts.

4th July 2018

Nothing better than Lagavulin and a good cigar. A match made in heaven.

3rd July 2018

As a relative newcomer to scotch, I "grew up" on the Johnny Walkers, Dewars, etc. ... this past Christmas, my wife (knowing my fondness for smoky flavor profiles in both food and beer, although not a scotch drinker, herself) had treated me to a bottle of Ardbeg, which I absolutely loved from the very first sip. More recently, she suggested that I try some Lagavulin 16, as her research indicated that it might be something that I would enjoy. Boy, was she ever right. To me, this is like a fruitier, more mellow cousin to Ardbeg. Just a beautiful and elegant sip, as long as you know what you are getting into. I'm still learning about scotch, but Lagavulin 16 was a most welcome and successful lesson. I give it an A+.

2nd July 2018

This is the only bottle in the world that I always make sure I have two of. An open one, and one behind it on case the zombie apocalypse comes before I can buy another. True story...

19th June 2018

I had my first taste of this whisky about 10 years ago and never looked back. It isn't for the meek or first time tasters but if you have been meddling with some other malts and want to go up and taste what it is like to taste the best, then treat yourself. Savour this flavour and you will never go back. This is the Usain Bolt of smokey whisky from Islay. Simply the best...

16th June 2018

This is by far one of the best whisky's I've ever drank.

13th June 2018

Warm, earthy, with just enough sweetness. If you don’t like smoke, don’t drink it. If you do, you won’t find a better Scotch.

12th June 2018

How can I have been so ignorant of this whisky until now? Absolutely outstanding, and by far the most balanced whisky I've had so far. I started off avoiding peated whiskies but this is so smooth and luxurious that the peat adds to it. As another reviewer commented, this is like the Rolls Royce of whiskies!

4th June 2018

One of Ron Swanson’s favorites!

3rd June 2018

Throw my 5 stars on to the pile, simply outstanding. The peat!

20th May 2018

I was treated (oh yes, it was a treat) to this by my son. My first thought was, "wait, what is this...oh my God!" I'm a novice, only been drinking single malts a couple of years; I don't have the nose, knowledge of most of those on this site.
All I know is that in all my 74 years I've never tasted any whiskey anywhere near this good. I've never had an emotional reaction to a whiskey before.
Many thanks to my son, Shawn.

15th May 2018

Spirit of Islay and Peated Whisky, perfect taste, smokey, sweet, peated, and strong, you should taste a new thing...where it simply described by Lagavulin 16YO... wonderful....

13th May 2018

Simply the Rolls Royce of whisky. I love taking my customers on a whisky tour of my bar and finishing off with this, the most perfectly balanced of all whisky, you could say the more expensive the car the more the engine knows what it’s doing..
Lagavulin 16 as described by the bike enthusiast of Beinglas..

5th May 2018

老女人

25th April 2018

Don't normally go for a peaty taste but this is so smooth I really like it. Yes it is smokey but the taste is so gentle. No real bite which i miss, but for a relaxing smooth dram can't fault it. very different from my usual but a welcome distraction.

12th April 2018

Very nice. Very wood smoke, quite complex and powerful. Taste very much different experience than smell.

Downfall is that it should not be coloured and should certainly not be chill filtered.

1st April 2018

How can anyone possibly have a "favourite" whisky? So many that are so good! But whenever I drink this it's like falling in love all over again. Incredibly smooth, deliciously smokey, and just enough creamy sweetness - beautiful smoked oyster flavours, and a warm, mellow afterglow that makes the world just back off for a while.


(PS - I can't stand Lapsang Souchong tea!)

23rd March 2018

I can’t believe all the 1 star reviews because this is too smokey! That’s as crazy as buying a Ferrari and giving it 1 star because it’s too fast.
Know what you’re drinking. Lagavulin is the daddy of smokey Isla’s. It’s certainly not a beginners drink, but when you understand what’s in your glass there’s no finer drop of whisky. Smokey, meaty, with a hint of angel’s tears and unicorn sweat. In short: it’s magical.

23rd March 2018

My new favourite - beats all other scotches I've tried by a landslide. Sweet, rich, warm, and meaty. If you have learned to taste past the smoke, it is incredible.

22nd March 2018

Although I don't ordinarily consider lifestyle advice from anyone in Hollywood worth a grain of salt, I have to confess I bought my first bottle of Lagavulin 16 because "Ron Swanson" (actor Nick Offerman) raved about it so much. The best whisky I have ever tasted, period, but not recommended for the "whine and cheese" crowd.

19th March 2018

It’s so smoky, yes. But also so balanced with sweet dark dried fruit and a lovely mint-like finish. I can’t find a better dram.

18th March 2018

definitely the best whisky I've ever tasted

11th March 2018

It is definitely Smokey, and it’s aromas are powerful. It is smooth, flavorful, and aged to perfection.

1st March 2018

I think it is attrocious. Tastes like I'm drinking a burned out forest fire. Awful. Threw it out.

28th February 2018

A work of art. Yeah there's smoke throughout, but it's not overwhelming and its beautifully balanced by a malty sweetness and sherry undertones. I love spending time alone with this bottle, and get a feeling of melancholy when I see the end is near. Like saying goodbye to a dear friend.

21st February 2018

I really prefer this compared to Ardbeg 10 and Laphroaig 10. Very smooth, earthy, smoky and rich flavour. It costs around 85€ where I live but for me it's the best isla whisky for under 100€ :)

20th February 2018

Quite simply a stunning malt. It takes a special whisky to call my favourite but Lagavulin 16yo is that whisky. Nicer than Lagavulin Distillers Edition (just). Enjoy with a little drop of water to bring out the flavours. Do not buy or give poor reviews if peaty malts are not for you.

20th February 2018

I recently had the chance to try 16 and 18 year old within 24 hours of each other so I had a bit of a think about the two. This is no small wonder for me as I am a cheap fan of great scotch(not easy!). I realize there are far more expensive bottles out there, but $50+ a bottle for me is above my price range at the moment. It won’t be for very much longer. I do not have a refined palette or nose, I do not know all of the technical terminology, but I know what I like and I loved the 16 and the 18 absolutely through and through. It is uncompromisingly bold and the most delicious whisky I’ve ever had my gums ‘round. The best way I can describe it to those on the fence about trying it is that it is absolutely like drinking the outdoors, if that were possible. Earthy, smoky and sweet, it reminded me of all my boyhood camping trips replete with nights around the bonfire and roasted marshmallows. I’m not sure what being a newcomer to drinking scotch has to do with anything, but if any of that appeals to you, do not hesitate to purchase this.

18th February 2018

It has been a while since I've a bottle of this whisky, which is strange since for years it was my favourite. I opened my new bottle last evening and was pleased to find it as excellent as I remembered. The nose was peat and sea and the first thing to hit me on the palate was the dry peaty smoke that ended with salt and pepper and went on forever. Great to get a 16 yo Islay for this price, too. Well done MoM.

17th February 2018

This is a scotch that is truly amazing...if you are in the right mood. I find it is best in cold weather. Especially for the price, it has extreme depth and flavor. However, if you don't like smoke, you definitely will not like this one. What I like is the way the smoke somehow transforms into sweet...on the nose and on the palate.

17th February 2018

Tastes like a camp fire

14th February 2018

Nirvanic waters, majestic malt, tindered stew, just plain delicious !!!

13th February 2018

Lagavulin 16's distinctive smokey notes and sweetness make this an excellent drink with a a cubano cigar with some smoked oysters. Kick your feet up and enjoy the vida loca.

13th February 2018

Never had a taste for Scotch whisky until I tasted this. Around here, it is $80 a bottle. I don’t buy it often, but it is the only Scotch I buy. And, I don’t share it with just anybody. Hard to believe people saying they didn’t like it because it was “too” smoky. I notice no middle of the road reviews. Love it or hate it.

13th February 2018

Somebody complained it was peaty!! outstanding scotch

5th February 2018

Not for me. The smokiness is over-powering and tastes like a chemical has been added like dettol. However it's probably a drink that you need to make you're way up to as opposed to just jumping in.

4th February 2018

Surprised someone buys Lagavulin 16 then punishes the whisky with 1/2 star because it's too smokey ??
I'd just say it's wise to do a little research before purchase. Among my favorites

31st January 2018

This was my go to for years & would get all the stars until I started to notice a drastic change in the palate. Maybe the 16yr old is running short? If you have a fantastic seller and product runs short what do you do? Go broke or start mixing? You be the judge.

28th January 2018

Nose:

Full and ritch iodine.
Peat.
Classic sea note (salty, tangy, rotten seaweed)
There is a little sherry note in the backround.
There is meat on the nose, smoked meat, pork chops, fish, etc
There also are some spices and wood notes

Overtime the iodine starts to mellow down, same with the peat.
Now there is a little more sherry and coastal notes.


Palate:

Full impact with a lot of great rich notes.
Iodine, coastal, oaky, and in the background some sherry notes (little plum)
Its spicy, there are a bunch of spices.
Nutmeg and a little cinnamon.
Meaty, something smoked from a pig? with some fish.


Finsih/aftertaste:

Now the barrel kicks in, chocolate, sherry notes.
Deep full rich milk chocolate, almost lile a pudding.
There is also oakyness, not to much.
Then this meaty feeling keeps hanging arround.

Its a really good whisky, I dont add any water, in my opinion it doesn't need it, but if you want you can add some, it can handle it.
When you leave this in the bottle sitting with about 3/4 left for a couple weeks/months it gets really rich and there is more meat and chocolate
and sherry.

Overall an amazing whisky and I am going to buy more.
Its a perfect product but I would love to see a little more abv and natural colour, normally I wouldn't give a whisky with lower abv and colour added
a 10/10 but the nose, finish, palate/aftertaste and of course the value is amazing so yes, this gets a 10/10 for me and it will always be one of my
favourites.

-Cheers!

28th January 2018

To much of a smokey taste

26th January 2018

Take a super high quality single malt Scotch whisky, sit it on your wood-fired grill for oh, say 45 minutes, and taste a miraculous transformation...that's Islay malt (don't ever really do this!!) and, more specifically, the king of Islay malts. I don't dislike Highlands, Campbeltowns, or Lowlands but if I were restricted to one whisky (or even one whiskey) Lagavulin would be my hands-down choice! The smoke and peat of the process, the influence of the hundreds-of-millions of years-old rocks, the char of the old oak casks... that's the heart and soul of a satisfying dram. Nothing better!

26th January 2018

just the right amount of everything with a long finish that just makes you want another one

21st January 2018

Smokey, sweet and savory, mouthwatering, slightly medicinal from the distinctive peat from the Isla shores that serves up this delicious and intoxicating love lava. You can't go wrong with Lagggy 16!

18th January 2018

iv just had a few drams of lagavulin white horse bottling and have too agree with others that it is better than todays bottles worth trying too find a bottle if you can

14th January 2018

My favorite dram. If you take a small sip on the front of your tongue, you taste the sweetness. If allowed to the back of tongue, you get all the smoky richness.

13th January 2018

The tasting note above was pretty much spot-on except for the finish. This is a wonderful scotch but not as smoky as I was hoping.

12th January 2018

just amazing....peated smoke...loved it.

10th January 2018

i didnt find any "smoke" .. its smooth like drinking water .. no alcohol bite AT ALL which is a bit awkward! .. nose ? iodine .. taste ? iodine and sherry all the way.

9th January 2018

Exceptional distinctive taste. As soon as this exquisite single malt from the best Scotch Whiskey producing region from the great land of Scotland touches your taste buds you know you have made a decision that will forever form your selection of Scotch Whiskey. There are many Scotch’s that have a hollow taste and you swallow as soon as possible but with the Lagavulin 16 you relish this fine whiskey coating your palate with the aromas of Smokey Peat, Scottish Sea Air, and the sweetness of vanilla. To each his own but as for me and my house Lagavulin 16 is what is served here.

8th January 2018

This is a must try for any true scotch fan. It carries a hefty price tag at $110 a bottle in my area but is as good as it gets . Try laphroaig 10 year for about half the price as a good alternate for an extra peaty scotch ... the laphroaig however is a bit more medicinal whereas the lagavulin has some excellent fruit notes . For any parks and rec fans out there , Lagavulin is Ron Swanson’s drink of choice

7th January 2018

Per Whiski Rooms, Edinburgh...Nose-Full on. Lot's of wood smoke, surrounding surprising sweetness. White pepper. Palate-Smoke, Marmalade, and toffee. Develops some oily notes. Sea air comes through towards the end. Finish-A dry finish, with that bear-hug of peat seemingly lasting forever. Couldn't agree more after my flight of peaty malts at Whiski Rooms...best of the peats for me. Sip it slow, exhale thru nose...beautiful. Add drop of water for slightly different bouquet.

6th January 2018

I’m not a specialist in Irish or scotch whiskey, but I had in years many of pleasant taste or very good, or exceptional
I bought among others, this 16 y old lagavulin, recently for a New Year gathering in my house. We opened it and found SMOKED POISON liquid inside the bottle! Disgusting! Never had in my mouth garbage like this, even in the college years... Take my advice, please... Don’t even try it, is real garbage!
What a waste of money... Something must be wrong with people giving stars to this product

5th January 2018

An excellent whisky. Could do without the colouring and all that as well as a well rounded 46% to make it even better. Can you find more unknown and better gems for the price? most certainly yes. However this cant be missed if you love peaty whisky. A true classic

4th January 2018

Disgusting

1st January 2018

Lagavulin is the first single malt I ever tasted and I guess I just took a liking to its complex palate and spicy finish. I like all the single malts, each one seems like it has something special to offer. This one just holds the top spot for me.

28th December 2017

If-ing you like the taste of creosote, with hints of kelp and a little touch of iodine, spent pipe tobacco, fishboxes and kippers, the this is the drink for you!
Have you ever walked though a house the day after it burned to the ground. That is what the smokey smell reminds me of, one big toxic ash tray.

It was slightly better after it was allowed to breathe for a while, or was that after the ice was allowed to melt?
If this is your drink, bottoms up.
You can have it.

28th December 2017

while strong peat
a balaced scotch whiskey

try a couple of ice cubes and let the evening grow richer

27th December 2017

I was very hyped about this, i tasted a lot of whiskies, but this is the first one that i so disliked that i didnt even finish my glass. It tasted like shoe polish/acetone. I just stick to my glenfiddich/glenmorangie/bourbons

25th December 2017

Too smokey for this American of Irish descent. Not quite as strong as those that make me feel as is I licked the campfire, but it just doesn’t work for me.

25th December 2017

Enjoyed looking at the bottle with a friend was not game to open it at $90 enjoyed a beer instead.

23rd December 2017

A friend is a dedicated Islay man.. im a novice, but wanted to see what the fuss was about.. Ive treated myself to a bottle of this... Novice or not.. this is spectacular.. Islay and Lagavulin 16 for me...when i have another excuse to treat myself! Wait..my birthday on January 1st.. first excuse covered!

23rd December 2017

It's like sitting downwind from a bonfire. I love it, and I'm a speyside guy. So masculine. I love it. Makes me live above my means like a true American.

17th December 2017

My boyfriend cites Lagavulin 16 as his favorite whiskey (of laphroaig and glenlivet, I think). It's smoky, oaky, and vanilla-y, really smooth. Also, though it is ultimately overpriced as others have said here, you won't find a better product and shipping price than at Master of Malt; other sites prompted me to pay $100+ to have Lagavulin 16 sent to my boyfriend.

My one complaint is about the gift message: I know it's free, but it comes in the form of a shitty sticker that I'm supposed to...what, stick directly on the bottle? Type or hand-write it on a pretty little card guys, c'mon. It's good whiskey, bejesus.

7th December 2017

If you don't like this you don't like Islay, I had a crazy Highland loyalist tell me he dumped half a bottle down the drain I probably would have given him at least $30 for it - smoke and peat all the way

7th December 2017

What a wonderful whisky. Powerfully smoky and rich. Sipping it now and loving it.

25th November 2017

What a wonderful whisky this 16 year old is. If I could afford it I would drink little else. Treat yourself.

19th November 2017

Great smoke flavor. Absolutely wonderful explosion on the palate, with a smooth follow-up. I love this Scotch.

18th November 2017

I’m no expert but I know what I like and this is very, very good. A multi-layered and surprising experience.

17th November 2017

Peat, campfire ashes, sweet and salty, brine, roasted chestnuts and aromatic notes of the sea. A Superb dram for the discerning Scotch drinker. Wish it were bottled at a higher abv.

6th November 2017

I'm also cynically unimpressed with the big corp mentality, and whilst it tuned my head to the dark side 25 years ago, it's not what it was, or maybe everyone else just does it better for less? I prefer Talisker 10, and Talisker Storm, in fact the Tesco only Highland Park Dragon thing is a more rounded and an equal a fist in a velvet glove perhaps. I think that Ardbeg has got the crown of the smoky peaty monster well and truly in its grip, and the Laga is not the benchmark it once was, especially at it's over now over-inflated price.

4th November 2017

The cognac of scotches.... like a depth charge, a sip goes whoooomphhh

4th November 2017

Oak and smoke,
that's not a joke.
Sherry and berry,
yes it's sweet,
and all the peat...
Then an old cigar
and a hint of tar.

But... Now my poem went too far..:)-

3rd November 2017

Great smoky taste. It's like an explosion inside your mouth with a gentle but heavenly smoky fire. It's awesome. Just love it.

3rd November 2017

Best wicket around! Not for beginners.

30th October 2017

I really enjoy the bold flavor, it is a new favorite. Excellent drink.

26th October 2017

First tried this while sitting around a bonfire. It has a great smoky flavor. I told my wife it was like I was drinking the bonfire. It is an excellent scotch.

22nd October 2017

The Lagavulin 16 is a calm explosion of nose, plate and finish. Fruity, smoky and incredibly rich. It exudes excellence and is well worth its price. However, it is a bit too sweet for my taste. Perhaps that is preferred by some, but this Lagavulin is in my opinion more suitable to accompany a desert. The sweetness simply becomes too overbearing when enjoyed on its own.

21st October 2017

I'm seeing reviews about how it has color added and it's cool filtered and how that affects the flavor. Who cares? I don't care what they put in it our what they take it if it. The only thing that matters to me is what comes out of the bottle and what comes out of the bottle is a darn fine whisky.

19th October 2017

Earthy smoke in the back with sweet and savory notes lasting long on the palete. Pulling the cork immediately brings a waft of Islay shores. Truly a classic dram for those who can afford it .

18th October 2017

While not the brawler that my usual Laphroaig is, it is a wonderful alternative for those times when I feel like a waltz instead of a tango. The glorious sweetness of the opening nose leads seamlessly to the gentle smokey peatiness on the pallet. It may not be perfect, but the belle de jour rarely is. Enjoy its sublime comfort.

14th October 2017

You love it or you hate it. I love it, absolutely love it. This drink is Sacred for me. It's outwordly.

12th October 2017

Been drinking scotch for 35 years and like many of the reviewers, have drank all the world class malts over the years. Have close to 20 bottles on my home bar at any given time; some purchased as gifts, some brought over Scotland by business colleagues and relatives and many hand carried by myself on my frequent trips. Had my first experience with this two nights ago resort in Florida. Neat, with a few drops of room temp tap water, one of best I've ever tasted. Have a case on order.....

7th October 2017

I like the comments of 'K' at least he is constructive and descriptive in hi summary and does instead of childish rants about meths and dettol utter rubbish.
There will be a difference of opinion as people have different tastes, please keep it informative!

7th October 2017

First time trying an islay single malt. Very good. Has the strong smokiness like fire burning on wood. Also has slight fruitiness and minty aromas in the smoke. Smoky flavors take time to adjust when used to caramel/toffee/vanilla/chocolate/fruit/butterscotch in speysides, highlands, lowlands, and japanese whiskies. Would have something smoky here and there but prefer the caramel/toffee/vanilla/chocolate/fruit/butterscotch tones.

6th October 2017

Peaty smoke that is perfect for rainy weather.

4th October 2017

The views that say acetone or meths... I concur, it was bought as a present for me and a 50 a bottle I am sure glad I didn't spend it on this. I'm more a fan of pleasant single malts and bourbons. Penderyn madeira , glenfiddich, glenmorangie and the southern bourbons.
I find it more like meths+dettol to taste. My view only. Each to their own

30th September 2017

I mean, just so complex and lovely. It may be a love it or hate it product, I am not sure, but I can hardly imagine not having at least one bottle on the shelf.

29th September 2017

I bought this in duty free, my bottle of ardbeg 10 was empty and i wanted another,but alas it was not to be. I was recommended this by the friendly salesman so I gave it a go, now to be honest the first few times I tried It, I really wasn't a fan, i could taste nothing but smoke and it was placed at the back of the cupboard and marked up as a poor impulse buy, I cursed the salesman and went about my life. 12 months later, this very night in fact, I find myself writing this review, my 4th dram in hand and a feeling of guilt that I was so quick to judge, the smokeyness is still there but there's so much more behind it, a warmness that takes me back to my beloved homeland, a sweetness that could only be born in Scotland. It may not be matured in Islay as a couple of people have mentioned but, it is Scotland in a glass,strong, powerful, earthy, with a sweetness you won't find anywhere else. Slàinte

28th September 2017

Stop reducing the quality of good malts Diageo. Stop chill filtering your malts, don't you get it. Make money by selling products that scream quality and not watered down inferior malts. You can only fool the new drinker who has never tried a non-chill filtered, natural colour malt.

26th September 2017

However much I would like to try Lagavulin 16, I would not for two reasons:
A: Lagavulin is not matured in Islay. Lagavulin as well as Caol Ila and Talisker are transported across the Scottish waters in stainless steel vats to the mainland where they are matured with other whiskies, therefore Lagavulin, Caol Ila and Talisker have absolutely no sign of the geography of Islay in their maturity. This makes a substantial impact on the flavour of the whisky and I care about that impact because Lagavulin costs quite a lot of money. That said, Caol Ila 12 and Talisker 10 are affordable so the damage is not as steep

B: The reasons stated above are acceptable if, and only if Diageo stops chill filtering and colouring Lagavulin 16. For the price point and owing to the fact that it is NOT matured in Islay, they ought to stop chill filtering and adding artificial colour. Only then would Lagavulin 16 be worth its price.

Therefore at the current situation it is a rip off. Chill filtration of single malts takes away a big portion of the flavour of the whisky and that is what we are paying for, the flavour not the brand. And no one wants a mediocre product at an inflated price point.

Anyone can test my claim, try any two single malts side by side, one chill filtered and the other non-chill filtered and you will know the difference is worth ranting over.

As long as we keep turning a blind eye towards these big corporations by playing into their marketing gimmicks and the many useless and overrated whisky awards, we will never get our money's worth.

26th September 2017

I had this for the first time last night, after returning from my trip to Scotland, where I decided peat is definitely my preferred taste. I describe this as having a smoky fireplace in my chest - I'm a 5'3 petite blonde and loved the experience! Can't wait to have it again ;-)

26th September 2017

Not the pleasant palate test after I consumed this whiskey, it's really not what I expected from it. I prefer something better like Oban, Macallan or similar much better then this junk.

24th September 2017

Simply the best

15th September 2017

For those who like Glenlivet and Glenfidich and other easy drinking Speyside Scotches---move on! This is Islay baby! Peat, smoke, brine, sweet and fresh fruit with a hint of iodine to finish you off. Clearly a Scotch for whom a discerning palate is a prerequisite. Slangiva!

4th September 2017

Initially, the smokey seemed a bit overpowering but after it opened up a bit this scotch became incredibly well balanced while still retaining the classic Islay profile. I find myself daydreaming of my next glass - a little unsettling but what are you gonna do?

23rd August 2017

Mouthwatering phenolic sweetness with smokey overtones, hints of spice and fresh fruit soaked in sour dough and nutty chocolate. My oh my!

21st August 2017

After 40 years drinking Johnny Black I decided to try something else. When I got my dream job I decided to celebrate with a bottle of Lagavulin 16. In my local ABC store that cost $100 so I expected to not be disappointed. I was disappointed. While it was undoubtedly smooth and full flavored, the smokey seemed overdone, sort of Liquid Smoke mixed with an ashtray. Perhaps it is a lack of taste on my part, but I think the Glenlivet 15 in French Oak Casks was far better and cost 1/3 less.

18th August 2017

For a 15 plus year aged scotch I expect a smoother experience but this scotch was lesser smooth than a 5 year bottom shelf. Yes the bouquet is promising and the first second on the front gives you hope, but then it becomes a petulant toddler throwing a temper tantrum. Save yourself the trouble and try something like Glenfiddich 18 or Glenlivet 20.

12th August 2017

Like another said, let it sit in your mouth for a while and swallow slowly. This is an incredible whisky. Just delicious.

20th July 2017

Best "Hillbilly" I ever had ( my own recipe 2 parts Lagavulin 16 and 1 part Drambuie on the rocks)

18th July 2017

The embodiment of Islay expectation... You had better like it smokey. Great mouth coating flavour. Quite pungent to begin with, but small sips & drunk slowly make this a satisfying and moreish whisky.

18th July 2017

I'm enjoying Lagavulin 16 for the first time right now, and this was a good call. It won't be the last time.

14th July 2017

Smoke, smoke and smoke....as I'm learning my way through Scotch world, I'm learning...

Nose is absolute smoke, very reminiscent of southern barbecue.

On the pallet is a roundhouse of tastes...finished with a sting of alcohol and more smoke. This whiskey feels like it is meant for unapologetic carnivores: big and in your face; not for "gentle folk".

I've never diluted a whiskey in my life, and I won't start with this one. If I were to settle in with a bottle for a long night, I'd probably want a salty snack of some sort to nibble as I sipped to keep everything balanced.

13th July 2017

Intense taste for sure. I'm more of a bourbon guy, but had to try this out. There was a depth of flavor here I wasn't used to. As well as flavors and smells that were familiar, but I couldn't quite place. This is something that I would recommend someone to at least enjoy once.

12th July 2017

Tasted it for first time tonight. Delightful sitting next to my bonnie wee bonnie lassie, Norma Joan in Southern California.

7th July 2017

Nose: Initially reminded me a lot of talisker dark storm but not as intense and rough. More complex, smoother and less aggressive on the nose. Peaty smoke, Iodine and salt like the sea, a deep sweetness like malt.

Mouth: Oily, rich and thick. Flavours similar to the smell coat the mouth. Smoke, some peat, saltiness, iodine and material from the sea. Met with some dark sherry or dark fruits sweetness with a malt like sweetness. A tiny hint of oak.

Finish: Like how your hair smells after an entire day at the beach and some smoke. Oily and lingers for a long while.

Would recommend to those who like their peaty/smokey whiskeys and i think it is definitely worth a try for everyone. Though i understand it may be a love it or hate it scenario, i think you should try it before you cross it off your list. A masterpiece of whiskey.

5th July 2017

well ! if you're psychotic man who loves to waste $40 for drinking betadine ? then don't hesitate! go for this one .. i'm sure you will be utterly satisfied! cheers X

1st July 2017

The best whisky in the world.
I've tried plenty of smoky Islay malts at this stage in life and nothing comes close.
As for Speyside, Orkney et al, they are are just lame in comparison to anything from Islay.
I wish I could afford to have a bottle permanently on the go.

30th June 2017

The best whisky in the world.
I've tried plenty of smoky, Islay malts at this stage in life and nothing comes close.

30th June 2017

As an amateur to single malts, I was unsure what to expect. If you're new to it, the first scent and sip will slap you around and take you off your feet. Give it time. Have a glass the next night (glencairn if you have it.)

It's been a few nights, I've enjoyed it very slowly. It's amazing. I can't describe the beautiful leathery feeling and taste. Expensive but worth it.

29th June 2017

Tastes like someone has set fire to a toffee factory using wrights coal tar vaporisers, amazing!

27th June 2017

Mitico, mitico, il mio preferito...questo Lagavulin 16 anni è veramente un Grande Whisky. Una profondità di sapori speziati, ma sempre equilibrati tra loro, al palato pungente al punto giusto, un Whisky da serata con un bel trancio di salmone in crosta di patate.

24th June 2017

Beautiful. Rich, smoky, a subtle sweetness with some spices and vanilla. Close your eyes and be transported next to a bonfire on a cold Scottish beach with the salty wind blowing in your face.

I may just have found a new favorite dram.

22nd June 2017

You must try it. I read before that this is a love it or leave it whisky. Some people hate. I don't get. It is breath taking. I can't stop drinking it :)) it is really rich. Yes there is a lot of pest but it's not just that- it's rich and sweet, very sweet and dry. It is completely different from all the other drams Ive tasted before. Wonderful.

21st June 2017

Sipping the Lagavulin 16 my wife picked up for me for Father's day...
This stuff is nectar of the Ghods! Very nice body, lush mouthfeel, and with decently complex flavors. 43% alcohol. It is from the Islay region. Home of some of the most famous Scotch made.

Nose: Smoke, vanilla, sweet spices...
touch of sherry. Alcohol is muted, barely there.
Palate: Thick and rich, sherry and sweet fruit, and of course... that smoke... delectable smoke, not slap the face, but muted strength, if that makes sense.
The finish is long, and wonderful with the smoke drifting off and a reminder that, yes, this is a whisky... something one can almost forget.

Overall, this is a very nice scotch. One that exemplifies what some age can accomplish with an Islay. It is luxurious, smooth, smokey with a reminder of sherry.
I highly recommend it, and thank my babydoll for picking it up for me 😄

18th June 2017

Wow. Caught me off guard.

14th June 2017

While driving in France I met an old friend in the food/drinks industry. He handed over his wee flask and I had a sip, silly me, I should have glugged it. He gave me the name Lagavulin and when I returned home I bought my first bottle. I drink Speyside whiskies in all their variety but Lagavulin 16 is the one I empty fastest.

13th June 2017

Such a good scotch! I'm not really good at tasting note so I won't go there, but I'm truly amazed by this juice. As the title says, I could drink this every day.

Those of you who say it is aweful probably a bad batch. I gifted a bottle of this to my brother-in-law and it's nowhere near as good as the bottle I own.

100% would buy again.

13th June 2017

I am stunned at some of the poor comments on here from others. This is a gorgeous whisky - one that I would happily drink until I pass off this mortal coil.

11th June 2017

Funny to read the moronic views of posters here who obviously have a palate on a similar level to their IQ's. Stunning dram, a privilege to drink such a perfectly crafted malt. Few finer drinks on the planet -including the best Bordeaux wines etc. Gorgeous.

11th June 2017

Absolutely disgusting. Tasted like turpentine. Going to cross this off my list and go back to Macallan, Glenmorangie, highland Park and my Dalmore

9th June 2017

Truly disgusting... Tasted like acetone!!!

9th June 2017

I love this whisky, I have and continue to try new whiskies every month but so far none compare to this.

6th June 2017

Find the peat too much for my liking when first opened. Did something crazy by matching it with red chillies... and the "enlightenment" moment happens! Still rich and smoky on palate, in fact with added spiciness, but the finishing is superb - with hint of herbs amidst the oaky sweetness. And I proceed to finish half a bottle, that says it all.

30th May 2017

Hello. I'm the Sugarbear. I've reviewed many whiskies on this website( mainly Scotch since it's the superior) and I am starting to run out of things to try. I am lucky enough to get this for $55 a bottle here in California even though it is typically between $75 and $100 at most stores. It is always in my collection and I'm finishing off my tenth bottle right now with number eleven on standby. This might be the perfect age for an Islay whisky if it were younger it would be peatier but not as smooth n oaky ( 8 year totally awesome) and if it were older it wouldn't be Peaty enough honestly. It's consistently amazing I truly love this whisky and I have to have it on hand at all times. To whoever poured this down the drain if you bought it you can do what you want with it ( but i hate you) and to those who gave it a low rating you probably don't enjoy bold/ complex flavors which is fine but you are boring. To whoever said that this is so good it brings tears to their eyes I completely agree with and to you I say ,Cheers! Slainte! The Sugarbear

28th May 2017

See title.

19th May 2017

It's good not great. Nice nose, mouth feel is thin and finish is med/short.

11th May 2017

Best Single Malt I've ever had! Add 2 fingers of Italian Sparkling Water and let sit for 5 mins. Very, very good!

10th May 2017

My first was bottle was in 2006. It immediately became my favourite and it still is in 2017. And for the price, it is simply outstanding.

24th April 2017

Long story, but eventually discovered the Islay brands. Basic inventory includes a coup le of Laphroaigs (10yr and cask), Ardbeg (Uigeadail), and Laguvalin 16. Plus Dalwhinnie for guests who think highland Scotch is the real thing. (Ok, I've also got some Chivas for cretins who want it with ice ir, God forbid, soda. Even had one person ask for Scitch and milk!)

But the Laguvalin is my favorite. Toss in a drop or two of water. Died and gone to heaven. Just touch it to your lips and let it spread across your taste buds. I truly cannot understand anyone who can drink anything else. This is without a doubt the finest Scotch made. Back in the BI era (before Islay) I was nearly apoplectic after finishing a bottle of 25 year old McCallan, but the Laguvalin changed all that.

Put it on your bucket list, but put it at the top. You won't regret it.

22nd April 2017

I actually gasped when I read a review a few under my one that said they poured it down the drain. What a waste!

This was the first whisky to truly get me hooked. My partner bought it for me on a whim for my birthday one year, on that gesture alone I should propose to her. What an absolute belter of a dram. Like drinking a bush fire. So smoky and complex. I always have a bottle on hand. You should too.

19th April 2017

I dont find this as peaty as laphroaig , but. A fine dram .

19th April 2017

One of the best there is. Cant go wrong with this one. But not during/after a dinner. The taste also improvs Over time. Wait a week or so after you opened it.

16th April 2017

hated it at first, very smoky and errr.... But wait, after after a few weeks, you might like it, seriously. It takes time to get use to the taste and once you do, you will love it too!

13th April 2017

I've heard great things about the 16, and so for my birthday my brother inlaw another Scotch drinker brought me a bottle. We cracked it open and couldn't wait to enjoy it, but when we took our first drink, Neat, it had the taste and smell of Campho - phenique. So we waited about 30 minutes to give out taste buds a chance to change, but it was the same. We drink all brands and types of Scotch but nothing like this. So down the drain it went just like our plans.

11th April 2017

I'll always remember my first experience of Lagavulin 16. Blew me away, truly. Sadly, the last two bottles I've purchased have been a real disappointment. They have seemed much more one dimensional than the first bottle and somewhat fragile when adding water. Maybe my palate has moved on. Who knows.

Still, not a bad whisky just below its historical par at present. I might wait 5 years before buying another LG16. I would recommend Laphroaig's Triple Wood & Old Ballantruan Peated Malt as worthy present day replacements.

6th April 2017

I don't typically rate scotches. Just like a painting, a sculpture, or even a fine cigar, the ratings is based on what we perceive and not the artistery of the creator. As another comentor below mentioned, Lagavulin and Talisker are two of the finest representations of great single malt scotches. I would add, for those who enjoy the unique characteristics of each. Lagavulin 16 is truly a masterful work of art, even if it isn't your palate, appreciate the artistery in crafting.

25th March 2017

Been trying various malts , just turned. 69 years old, getting a good taste for whisky. Really liked this 16 yr lagavulin, will definately buy it

16th March 2017

Taste is supreme! tks

14th March 2017

A citrus tang drifts in and out of a huge cloud of smoke - all on a bed of silky, luxurious malt. Brine and seaweed fade into a finish that goes on and on. One dram of Lagavulin, and the $90 price tag feels like a bargain.

11th March 2017

Smoky sweet for sure. Great taste and fantastic finish.

10th March 2017

This is my whisky! What an incredible rich taste!

6th March 2017

The cognac of whiskies

3rd March 2017

Amazing smoky sweet flavor as described. A little bite on the back end, but very tasty.

2nd March 2017

This is only my second bottle of Scotch, just opened two evenings ago (first bottle was Balvenie Double Wood 12). I have to say that I really like it! There is not as much smoke as I thought. I had tried a Laphroig at a friends place, and found it showed much more smoke, with not much else coming through (I'm very new to this). In contrast, the Lagavulin had smoke at the start, but also the sweetness of the sherry came through. I much prefer the Lagavulin. My favourite dram of all those I have tasted so far.

25th February 2017

I'm buying more!

22nd February 2017

the negative reviews are hilarious... easily the best everyday whisky... nothing comes close... this is a very special drink

19th February 2017

Lagavulin 16 is my second favorite scotch that is below the $100 mark in the States. (1) Lagavulin 12 (3) Ardbeg 10. Fantastic stuff.

19th February 2017

Not for the novice scotch drinker. A must for every scotch cabinet. Campfire in a glass. Definitely the smokiest dram you will ever have. Don't start with this in a scotch life or evening....but finish with it!

15th February 2017

My most favorite single malt. Tremendous character. Really tastes like whisky.

13th February 2017

This was the first Islay malt that I loved, and remains the whisky that I love the most. I'm nothing close to a peat head as my next three favorites are all highlands. (for perspective: Highland Park, Glenmorangie, Balvenie) Aside from Ardbeg Auriverdes (limited, rare, and somewhat overpowering) this one is more pronounced than I can imagine a whisky being, without being offensive to someone not accustomed to Islay peat. It's much less phenolic than Laphroaig and Ardbeg and yet still the smoke is pronounced enough without smelling like an old gym shoe on fire. This whisky is incredible and will perhaps remain my absolute favorite indefinitely. Before trying this, or any Islay malt, I'd recommend the Highland Park 12 (or 15 if you can find it) first. Theirs is a nice stepping stone to the smokiness that this one provides.

13th February 2017

Great smoke. One of my favorites. Especially the long after taste. Genuine whiskey!!

12th February 2017

Some Hype. Sorry but this is horrible.

5th February 2017

The Emperors new clothes. Taste like a smokey bandage. Nasty after taste will not die. Worst scotch I've ever had.

4th February 2017

The best single malt Scotch I've ever tasted

23rd January 2017

New to the World of Scotch, Lagavulin has become one of my favorites. Scotch being an acquired taste I am glad I have matured.

22nd January 2017

I bought a bottle of Laphroaig Quarter Cask 2 years ago. Tried it. Finished it. It was too much like a $5 grocery store cheesecake... big and thick and unrefined.

Saw Lagavulin 16 on sale so thought maybe I should give Islay another try. Folks, this one is the real deal.

If Laphroaig Quarter Cask is corner bakery then Lagavulin 16 is a high tea.

22nd January 2017

YOU SAY IODINE I SAY SHOE POLISH. 10/10 WOULD DRINK AGAIN. THE MORE U DRINK THE MORE U ENJOY.

21st January 2017

I have first tasted it in Wien/Austria in a whiskey pub. The best smokey one I have tried. Definetly in my own collection always. Such a smokey and at the same time such gentle...wow

13th January 2017

Excellent

12th January 2017

Has been my favorite since the beginning! Just an amazing dram!

7th January 2017

got bought a bottle if this for my 30th birthday was not disappointed lovely smokey peaty whisky can't see this bottle lasting me long

3rd January 2017

Got a bottle for Christmas. My son and I enjoyed it greatly. We will savor the jewel for months to come. Excellent

31st December 2016

I sent this as a gift and the recipient was very pleased. Thank you for a pleasant shopping experience and a great product at a fair price.

28th December 2016

Rather overwhelming peat smoke and TCP. Intense for sure, probably an acquired taste though.

26th December 2016

Love this bottle. Got it for Christmas and boy what a great taste. The smokiness hit me as soon as I pulled the cork and what a great aroma. The first taste was like heaven. The smokiness reminded me of a pipe tobacco and the sweetness rounded out the flavour. This scotch goes down so smooth and warms the soul.

26th December 2016

A lovely whisky for those who have a mature palate. You need to take a good swig and allow it to sit in the mouth for the flavours to burst out. First time I tried it it brought a tear to my eye. Its not to everyone's taste though you either love Islay whiskies or you don't. Inexperienced palates beware.

24th December 2016

A great sipping whisky. Smoke and pest and smell of the sea. Unique and unforgettable.

21st December 2016

I´ve drunk many a good single malt of any age and this chemical tasting dram was the worst. 45 euro down the drain...

18th December 2016

One of my faves. This and Talisker are some of the finest examples of single malts I have tried. My taste leans towards the west, as Highlands and Speysides can be a bit too sweet for me. Lagavulin was the first Islay I tasted and remains one of the best for me. I think the negative reviews are from those who sip - you just can't do that with an Islay! Hold a mouthful on your tongue and savour it. Wait! The let it slide down your throat. Smooth, intensely warm and sensual. Massive flavour which opens up as you swallow it.

I find if you drink it slowly you get less iodine and more warm smoky richness. If it tastes thin then you are sipping it or drinking too fast. No good drink tastes good sipped. Lagavuin 16 is not just a drink, it's an experience.

17th December 2016

One of the first whiskies I ever tried, in the drawing room of an old castle, and it completely converted me. Incredible complexity and very peaty - gorgeous for a cold winter's night.

12th December 2016

Hello peatness my old friend! There is much speculation and debate about who is the peat master in southern Islay. I confess that for me Ardbeg is most often like making out with a barbecue. One of Ardbeg's expressions is the only single malt I'd ever consider embellishing with added ice. Seriously. So, Lagavulin and Laphroig. Honestly, I go both ways. Having tasted a 42 (!) year old barrel of Lagavulin on site, I became a true believer though I can't give up my square foot of Laphroig peat bog. The 16 year old is an accessible standard bearer for Islay and peat. Definitely there, a wee bit in the nose, more on the palate, the memory in the finish. For me, it is how Lagavulin marries the peat with the sea. The nose has that great salinity that reminds you that you are not only on an island, but one that is off the coast of another island. The finish is all peat and seaweed for me. I'd recommend picking up a bottle, making the drive and walk to the American Memorial at the Mull of Oa, looking for the ubiquitous rain clouds between Scotland and Northern Ireland, and raising one to those who have died at sea. This dram is a worthy honour to those souls.

9th December 2016

I'm really stunned at how much I dislike this whisky. I'm not normally a peat fan and prefer speyside but I do appreciate the likes of laphroaig 10 and ardbeg uigeadail. For me this doesn't taste or smell of peat smoke, it tastes of cigarette ash and an unpleasant medicinal flavour.

8th December 2016

Top of the Islay league. But Ardbeg 10 yo is pretty close.

1st December 2016

I purchased, this month, a bottle of LAGAVULIN Islay single malt scotch whisky 16 years, after about 15 years. I remember a great whisky peaty,full and pleasant taste.
This seems a standard quality whiskies which was added an aroma of poor quality smoke. Leaves an unpleasant aftertaste.

29th November 2016

Stunning. The top cat of peaty malts. Should be on everyone's Christmas list.

27th November 2016

Wonderful stuff south africa loves it very smooth no headache in the morning need i say more .i dnt think so

27th November 2016

Peat and a little sweet. Nose is campfire and perfume, gritty yet colorful. My all time favorite.

22nd November 2016

At first, I wasn't quite sure that I wasn't to like this: the smell is distinct and the whisky is clearly – and uncompromisingly – peaty. However, after finishing off the bottle much quicker than expected I was fully convinced that this is a brilliant scotch.

21st November 2016

Just purchased a bottle from Costco Nr chester really looking forward to opening this later near Christmas time this is my first bottle after reading the reviews ,I would like to visit. Islay to see how the whisky is made

20th November 2016

I personally favor Lowland and Islay Scotch especially. I tried Lagavulin 16 for the first time and it was an epiphany of the entire soul of Scotch. The peat is massive and undeniable. Certainly not for the weaker palate. But it is so rich.and complex beyond that. I was simply floored at the beauty of this drink. 3 ounces, 2 cubes.

19th November 2016

Good peated whisky!

18th November 2016

One word ; Excellent .

15th November 2016

Lagavulin 16 is the Scotch drinkers think of when it comes y Islay Scotch. Great peaty smokey flavor. One of my standard Scotches.

14th November 2016

The best value whiskey I've ever had!!!

14th November 2016

Very nice. I think watery feeling some reviewers comment on is actually the dryness of the dram. It doesn't have the iodine hit of the 12yo cask strength but wait awhile and you'll get a subtle hint.
Very pleasing dram.

3rd November 2016

Wonderful taste. Thick and rich taste is unmistakable

30th October 2016

A bit to intense smokey for my palate. Review/flavor profile is very accurate. I didn't get as much peat as intense smoke.

27th October 2016

I believe this is a love it or hate it scotch. If you like smoke and peat, this is the one. There is a wonderful brine and salt finish with a hint of vanilla and coffee. Tastes differ, but this is my all-time favourite scotch. But at $125 per bottle in Canada, I don't drink it very often.

22nd October 2016

As someone who appreciates 'smoother/warmer' scotch (eg. Glenlivet distiller's reserve) I'm having a hard time adjusting to the extreme peat, smoke, and weird mix of dry with subtle sweet notes. Can't say this is a favourite.

21st October 2016

Wonderful whisky and good value

19th October 2016

I discovered this marvelous whisky when the waiter brought this instead of the one I'd ordered. Never have I been so happy with a mistake. I have shared this with friends after supper, in celebration and in commiseration. I have sipped this rich smoky, full-bodied mix of peat, barley and the distiller's magic alchemy around campfires watching for meteors and getting philosophical. The aroma of wood smoke evokes fond memories of this magnificent dram.

16th October 2016

WOW!!!!!
Gorgeous

8th October 2016

My son bought my first personal bottle of Lagavulin 16 for my 60th birthday; a treat for certain. Not being at all acquainted with the nuances and complexities of a finer bottle of Scotch whisky, I was at first somewhat overwhelmed by the taste of smoke and peat, mixed with something I might almost refer to as...antiseptic or medicinal.

My son recommended I hold a mouthful in for about ten seconds, then slowly as possible begin the swallowing process. As I began to do so, I experienced, after about 8 seconds or so, a near explosion of flavors quite unlike the peat moss taste that had been at the forefront of my initial go at it. A woodsy flavour, one accompanied quite nicely with a tad of decent sherry, became quite pronounced. I am, even as I write this review, enjoying a two finger splash of the whisky over two cubes of ice. Perfect for what ails ya! Cheers!

7th October 2016

Perfection

2nd October 2016

From my perspective the best balance between sweetness, smokiness and earthiness.

1st October 2016

Well this has been my first 'disappointment' as a whisky, sadly! My bottle, anyways, is not what I would describe as rich or thick - it's quite thin and does not stand up to any water being added, and I mean a drop!

It is very sweet and smoky though, with lovely licorice and ginger bread notes and a nice smoky/tea bag finish; not unpleasant by any means but was not what I expected given reviews and tasting notes I have come across. Have to say that the 16 years have definitely created an easy drinking spirit that does indeed have 'the fire taken out'. Possibly a bad batch or tired casks?

My lowest rating given - I don't feel that for the price I was getting the quality that, say for £2-3 extra, I would have got from an Uigeadail. Maybe I had too high expectations but I've had better whiskys for much less. 46% and NCF would also help!

25th September 2016

Opening this bottle and taking a sniff you get a hint of formaldehyde and antiseptic. When you try to drink it it gets worse. The formaldehyde flavor over powers everything but the dirt, and the finish is a mix of sawdust and iodine.

24th September 2016

There will always be mixed reviews when it comes to Singles. This 16yr Old is one of my favorites. Peaty and Smoky on top of peat and smoke, might be too much for some people but if you like earthy scotches this is KING! More flavor then you can imagine and yet it remained smooth and creamy. A must try for everyone.

18th September 2016

First taste I wasn't too taken, the next night I added a few drops of tap water and it was transformed into the best Whisky I have ever tasted
Love it

18th September 2016

While some you more "refined" connoisseurs may appreciate this gut rot, this particular distillation curled up my taste buds. A friend described it as "earthy" I replied, "NO, I think you mean Middle Earthy....you know like aged in an Orc's a...". Anyways, if you enjoy this, then more power to you. I'm pretty sure its also Sauron's favorite. I could've saved $80 and chewed on my hiking boot after trudging them through a boggy swamp. oi oi oi

13th September 2016

This is the peatiest, smokiest dram I have ever had the displeasure of consuming. It's like drinking old shoes that have been in a fire.

9th September 2016

My first taste of a peaty scotch was laphoaig quarter cask. At first it was odd. An acquired taste for sure. But it grew on me and the more it mellowed the better it became. So I bought a Highland Park 12 and at first I thought there was nothing special aside from the smoke, but it quickly settled down a bit after opening and It was a great experience. Since then I've had other peaty scotches like Laph. 18 & Talisker. I had read and seen many reviews on Lagavulin 16. Too many great reviews to ignore it. I ordered some in a pub on vacation. Tasted great from the first sip. Smoky, flavorful and balanced. I the tried it again at a friends house and I decided to buy my own. So I went to my local shop and finally brought it home. I open the bottle and take a sniff… and nothing. Thought that was odd. I pour a small dram into my glencairn glass and still a faint smell with not much smoke. Now I taste it and I'm stunned. Sweet, smooth…sweet again with a little bit of smoke. What happened to this? It tastes weak and mellowed out like almost a drink left out over night. What a waste of $90! I contacted lagavulin and I'm still waiting to hear from a quality control rep. I know what it's supposed to taste like but at its price I will not be willing to roll the dice and hope to get a "good batch" in the future. My first real disappointment in single malts. As I have tried many. What a shame.

8th September 2016

reminds me of the old coal miners sweets very smokey tastes of vanilla and peat aswell dandilion and burdock almost in a way one of the best islay available one to try at least once in your life

7th September 2016

Absolutely perfect

4th September 2016

This is the whiskey this got me into collecting to begin with. I've had 300+ whiskies including many over $200-$600 and worlds best whiskies. But this one always holds a special place in my palate. It's just perfect in every way. 10/10

30th August 2016

the best so far

28th August 2016

I have had 150 different Scotches in the last several years. This is one of my favorites! It is the perfect blend of peat and sherry.

27th August 2016

Nectar of the gods.

21st August 2016

Thick, Rich, Smooth......
A definite addition to the stable!

21st August 2016

Standing in the whiskey section, new to the whole Scottish Whiskey thing (besides reading a review or two and loving me some Glenmorangie). A woman walks up and asks me if I had tried Laphroaig. I told her no and that I had only read in review that it was good. She then pointed out to me Lagavulin and told me how her friends loved it so much and ONLY drank Lagavulin but that she wanted to get something new to try. Though I was of no help to her, she helped me a great deal and I snatched up Lagavulin as my first Islay purchase and my god was it a great purchase. Being a Glenmorangie Higland whiskey fan boy I obviously love me so full bodied, rich, and sweet whiskey but Lagavulin has shown me why it is everyone loves Islay Scottish Whiskey so much! It is basically the complete opposite of a Highland yet I crave it throughout the day! Such an amazing whiskey and one that from now on will always have a place on my shelf!

20th August 2016

Love taste of isle of islay

19th August 2016

Love this stuff, always have it on hand.

18th August 2016

This amazing scotch whiskey is really a gods gift and if you haven't tried it, you haven't lived.
Literally Amazing

16th August 2016

Always a treat.

13th August 2016

This used to be something spectacular. A unique earthly delight. Now it's more run of the mill. What the hell happened? I miss the bombast and experience of the old Lagavulin. This literally tastes watered down. I don't know if that violates a law in the UK for the production of spirits but whatever this is violates my soul and leaves me wanting. I hate to say it, but I will not buy this again.

11th August 2016

Tastes watered down. Is this the same thing as before? Where is the flavor. Wasted my money on this... Not a bad scotch as it is but hardly a 1st place winner.

11th August 2016

Best Scotch I've tried to date mmmmm so sweet and smooth (:

8th August 2016

So god damn smooth

4th August 2016

Beautifully matured to deliver a very pleasant experience to all and I mean all of drinking a healthy west coast malt - Slainte to all!

1st August 2016

The smokiness of this scotch is akin to a campfire. This has quickly become my favorite scotch. If you are not sure about purchasing this liquid gold, curb this doubt and make it a priority to obtain it.

31st July 2016

Great whisky! Reminds me a lot of bacon. Very salty and full, but not in an oily way. Reminds me of long fishing days on the beach by the campfire.

29th July 2016

@maltmondays

The Nose; Remarkably complex, theres refined natural smoke & peat balanced with true sweetness, its not a light sherry sweetness but a heavy rich honey like sweetness. As expected from an Islay the Sea is roaring in the glass, blackened drying seaweed as well fresh life giving sea algae jump to the top of your sinuses.

The Taste; Salt returns, the smokiness is more subdued in the taste then the nose. the sweetness is now wrapped in oak textures. This is a real mouthful, full-bodied and challenging. Buttery figs & dates add a winter character to the taste.

The Finish; Long and engaging. the thick nature of the smoke wraps itself around your tongue, hence the Kraken reference; salty tenticles from the deep blue sea engulf your tongue much like the ancient imagery of the Kraken or early interpretations of remarkable but very real giant Squid and octopus (both a great food pairing!) The lingering taste continues, warm & subtly sweet.. The last note being a oddly sweet brine like bitterness.

26th July 2016

For my money, this is, simply, the best whisky in the world for under $100, perhaps the best period. Most readily carachterized by intense smoke, PEAT, iodine, and sea spray; it smells and tastes like a campfire on a beach -- pure ambrosia.

23rd July 2016

I had wanted to try Lagavulin for almost 20 years. Honestly, the $100 price made me nervous. When I got my dream job- CIO of a hospital I decided to treat myself. However, I checked here and it seemed the 15 year old Glenlevit in French oak kegs rated slightly higher (at 2/3s the price).

Last month I turned 60 and bought the Lagavulin. It is the smoothest single malt I ever tasted. However, I won't buy it again. I suppose my palate is not sophistcated enough, but it tasted like someone took the words smoothest whiskey and then poured in half a bottle of liquid smoke. I think it gave me heartburn. The peat is a little strong too, bit it's the smoke that ruined it for me. As I say- its likely my lack of sophistication. At least it did not set off the smoke detectors.

21st July 2016

I finally got my hands on this and opened it up last weekend. The nose is very very concentrated, almost overpowering everything else with the seaweed/iodine flavors. But wait... a definite whiff of vanilla sweetness emerges?

The palate is more raw seaside than other great Islays - has an edgier feel, more briny, seaweed-y. Then the smooth sweetness takes over with the peat lurking in the background. A hint of meat?

The finish is spicy, smoky.

Aaah...if on a winter's night a traveler... walked in tired and weary, put his feet up beside a fire and savored a dram....

Compared to the Ardberg 10, this is more "wild ocean"...the 10 is sweeter, fruitier if you will.
Compared to the Ugi - the Ugi is more quicksilver with all the coffee, cocoa, and brown sugar notes.

This seems to be the perfect balance between a Laph 10 (which I find unrefined beyond a point, sorry) and the Ardberg 10.

4.5 solid stars

18th July 2016

Very balanced smokey leathery sweetness, I've never tasted anything like this.

14th July 2016

A perfectly balanced single malt , smooth and has a great finish! So glad someone recommended it.. Getting hooked !

14th July 2016

Nose: Smoke, Sweetness, Dry Peat, Mature & very complex

Taste: Oak, Salt, Small Sweetness, Full, Rich, Butter, Dates

Finish: Long - full of ripeness and smoke

Not a beginners peated whisky in my opinion, a great taster for the experience drinker!

9th July 2016

When God finally finished creating the heavens and the earth on the 7 th day, on the 8th day he opened a bottle of Lagavulin to celebrate what he achieved.

3rd July 2016

It's like the best Cuban cigar in a bottle!! Superb.

1st July 2016

Complex stormy flavors where oaken ships sweet with exotic fruit role on crests of smoky waves for what seems an eternity. If you only drink one bottle scotch in a lifetime let it be this one.

30th June 2016

This is an amazing creation, it's like drinking peat and fire!

27th June 2016

Cannot go wrong with this ... a benchmark for peaty single malt whiskies.

22nd June 2016

Bought this bottle on a lark and the first time I tried it I thought it was awful. Then the next day something said I should try it again. That has been happening now to the point I am going to have to order another bottle. I definitely wouldn't have liked it a year ago but as my tastes have matured so has my love for this scotch.

22nd June 2016

A complex, peaty whiskey which is the one I drink most frequently even though I have several other Isaly whiskies in my cabinet.

19th June 2016

Lagavulin was recommended to me by a waiter in Cefalu, Sicily. I am now obsessed with the smoky rich bite.

18th June 2016

The best of everything in one dram

10th June 2016

Where has the smoke gone? Its not the dream it was two years ago let alone ten. Shame on you diageo

9th June 2016

I was lucky enough to get about a triple measure for just a few euros in Italy today, I don't think the barmaid knew what she was pouring! Full of flavour with plenty of smokiness, it seemed perfect in the warm weather but I can imagine this being great on a cold night in. I would highly recommend a bottle of this sophisticated scotch and will definitely buy one myself.

2nd June 2016

This won't just put hairs on your chest it'll make your god damn balls drop.
Superb Islay.

2nd June 2016

Sophisticated flavor. My favorite whiskey

2nd June 2016

Starts well, decent smoke without the TCP of younger/ cruder Islay's, middle is full and fruity (read any of the reviews below) - and the finish goes on for some time in the same fashion. Many folk will like this whisky for it's simple macho smoke and look for nothing more, especially at this price.

Reason for only 6/10 is that overall it REALLY lacks complexity or interest - despite the smoke its a bland commercial product delivering little development or evolution in the glass. I look for more in a whisky especially at 16 y/o

30th May 2016

Most exquisite Scotch Whiskey ever made!

30th May 2016

Just right smoke with fabulous finish and deep aroma without overwhelming the nose or palate

27th May 2016

I'm a bit of a newbie to the whisky appreciation scene so I'm always willing to find my new favourite. I love Talisker and Singleton, also very partial to Laphroaig. For me Lagavulin took the best parts of these 3 and created a taste explosion! I may well have found my new favourite. It's not what this whisky is underneath but what it does that defines it!!

24th May 2016

The finest

22nd May 2016

Excellent Islay Single Malt!

22nd May 2016

Best

20th May 2016

How come such an exotic alcohol has such a repulsive smell.

20th May 2016

I recently brought a bottle of L16 to a poker game with friends. They are not experienced scotch drinkers and there were many different liquors available, but the entire bottle quickly went down their throats with gusto and approbation. Always a pleasure to expose new scotch drinkers to this fine Islay. This one will always be one of my favorites.

17th May 2016

Excellent Scotch, I've drank many, many different labels from both, Islay and the highlands and this one is superb, the richness and concentration are outstanding.

14th May 2016

Incredible.Proper whisky for grown ups.

4th May 2016

It is a wonderful malt,

1st May 2016

I'm a long term Islay fan and have been nursing a bottle bought at Norwegian prices. Suffice to say when I managed to cork it, the remainder ended up in a plastic water bottle. Am now hiding the evidence and enjoying the mellower sherry/vanilla/toffee notes with the usual after kick.

For me best enjoyed neat in what appears to be a stemless cognac glass.

29th April 2016

Amazing malt, truly is, second best in Islay, behind Ardbeg Corryvreckan.

29th April 2016

Islay beauty it is

26th April 2016

No words. Thank you lord.

25th April 2016

The best Islay whisky there is ..

17th April 2016

its frigging good , you will love it ONLY if you know what whiskey is .. smoke , peat , sherry , i swear to you guys i had a glass of that monster and walked 15 minutes from my hotel to the mall and still the finish is lingering!! look .. if you are one of these guys "whiskey coke , whiskey soda .." better to avoid it .. because lagavulin will kick your arse ! this .. is real men drink .. not suitable for youngsters .. it's dangerous:)

14th April 2016

An Islay lover, I never cared for this one. Annoyed that everyone else adores it, I kept trying. Rotten mushrooms I kept tasting. Everything else was "okay", but couldn't get over the rotten mushrooms.

Three bottles over two years, and finally I get it. For me the secret: do 50/50 water. Or more. I'm generally not a water-adder (did I just say that?), even to e.g. A'bunadh, but some water really brings this one out for me. Kills that concentrated rotten mushroom essence, and opens up whole new layers of complexity. The other Islays (Corryvreckan notwithstanding) don't take water nearly as well, and in retrospect that says something.

There's much more to this than smoke.

12th April 2016

É o melhot single malt . Já tenho o costume de toma- lo no momento estou degustando esrs maravilha sempre que viajo compro 2 garrafas , esta terminando e preciso comprar mais . Minha nota é 100.

11th April 2016

Avid Gin drinker who was convinced to get a new perspective on Scotch. Lagavulin 16 is a fantastic place to start. Head and shoulders above the others I've tried thus far. Had as much fun smelling this as I did drinking it.

10th April 2016

Nectar of the gods........

7th April 2016

delicious

6th April 2016

Earthy peaty smokey ...A flavour that lingers and sweetens as it subdues, an acquired taste very unique.

6th April 2016

Definitely an acquired taste. Not for anyone new to the game. Peaty and medicinal, but a well balanced single malt for the experienced single malt drinker. Great finish.

3rd April 2016

For me it just doesnt get better than this. Rich smoky complex perfectly balanced. Head and shoulders above any other single malt I have tried. Just magnificent.

1st April 2016

This beautiful, rich whiskey has a power to entice you. It's rich, deep with a long finish. Pitty but not overly so, with a beautiful hue of Polish amber.

1st April 2016

Huge smokey nose and taste.

27th March 2016

I love Talisker, and this whisky beats it. I'm a McKinnon, so that hurts.

21st March 2016

While some may consider Laphroaig 10 almost medicinal, Lagavulin 16 has the peat and iodine of Laphroaig nicely balanced with the smooth complex smoky nature of a 25 year-old from The McCallan. A longtime favorite of mine (and many of my friends) amongst commercially available single malts.

20th March 2016

Been taking the scottish medicine for quite a few years now - lagavulin is the very best value by far. To get any better you need to spend £100's. Add a little water (tiny drop) to break it up and it is transformed into a smooth delightful dram - not gonna get ponsy about hint of this etc, is down to your tongue. If you are new to Malt maybe start on a lowland light fruity number before moving onto the speys and islays.
Malt - its not business its personal. ENJOY.

18th March 2016

The first Scotch my wife enjoyed! Great with my steak, or after the meal. Wonderfully smooth.

18th March 2016

This is by far my favourite whisky that I have tasted to now. A complex and smooth drink that I cannot help but return to. Masters the note of smoke (which in my opinion can often be overdone) and so can be enjoyed by a larger audience. I will continue to purchase this, and I recommend to anyone "on the fence" to go for it, you won't be disappointed.

16th March 2016

Simply being Scottish certainly doesn't make me the last word on Scotch, plus all tasters enjoy differing palates, however, I know what I enjoy and when a flavour excites me.

Such was not fully the case with Lagavulin, however, I would be amiss if I were not to mention that 'spilling' 2 shots into a nearly full 5th of Glenlivet-12 (a gift from someone who apparently does NOT know Scotch) created a very enjoyable 5th of "GlenLAGAlivet".

I hope by now you're chuckling, but please know this is a true story, and the moral is, if the Laguvulin is that redeeming in a mostly full 5th of Glenlivet-12, then perhaps YOU should try it.

Smooth is the operative word when I begin to describe my experience of enjoying my first tasting of The Lagavulin.

Oh, I must also mention I do not particularly enjoy a heavily smoky Scotch, hence I may be somewhat negatively bias herewith, still, an honest 4.5 stars for The Lagavulin, an uncanny smoothness.

16th March 2016

I've tried over 10 different Scotches (Just started drinking Scotch), and I must say that this is a mans drink. I want a steak with every sip! It's smooth, powerful, and very tasty. I feel more like Ron Swanson with every glass!

16th March 2016

I've tried over 10 different scotches (just started drinking scotch), and I must say that this is a mans drink. I want a steak with every sip! It's smooth, powerful, and very tasty. I feel more like Ron Swanson with every glass!

16th March 2016

So, guys, my original thought was that this reminiscent of mezcal: no, this was entirely wrong. This is supreme and excellently balanced. This is just a good scotch whisky.

12th March 2016

If you fancy angels piss, then this is the bottle for you. Savor every last drop, and then go buy more.

10th March 2016

I don't understand how any Scotch drinker can't like this. I've had multiple bottles over the years and have enjoyed them all. I have tried many other Scotch whiskys, but this is the one I ALWAYS have in my pantry.

8th March 2016

A deep, West peaty whisky. My favorite!

8th March 2016

I hate to share-
I love this single malt to the Core.
It's smooth
It's smoky
It's satisfying
It's exciting
It's a Wow.
My favorite all time whiskey.

6th March 2016

This is my first time trying your Scotch. I had it after a nice meal at a restaurant and decided to try it. Asked if it was better neat or neat with water and was told to try both ways. Definitely better with a dash of water. The vanilla and spices come through the nose and the palate is superb. I may have to invest in a bottle. Cheers!

6th March 2016

This is an excellently balanced tipple. Not the crazed, unbalanced madness of Laphroaig or the mezcal notes of Arbeg. This is smooth and easy going.

25th February 2016

This is great. Not the best Islay but still tasty.

21st February 2016

From the powerful aroma, the taste leaves nothing to the imagination of this scotch . If you like to excite the senses in a little delicate way ... this is your drink. However I do not recommend it for those who like delicate and mild flavors .

19th February 2016

This is possibly my favourite whisky: as soon as I've finished a bottle, I replenish it.
It's an utterly unique and original dram and I can't think of anything else like it. As the description says: it really is a full mouth flavour: ash, smoke and peat followed by vanilla (almost slightly salted). This certainly isn't a dram I'd give to mates of mine who are just starting to try whisky, but I've recommended it to those who are interested in something big and beautiful. If you're put off by peat, then I'd recommend trying a sample (either from this site, or buying a dram in a bar), just in case it's not for you. Each to their own after all!

18th February 2016

Every time I try any other whiskey I find myself comparing them to this, and so far, without question, no other really compares or makes me smile the way this one does. There's just something about it...

18th February 2016

Truly a masterpiece! And its affordable!

17th February 2016

Love it 96 out off 100

13th February 2016

So glad I bought a bottle of this. I've had very cheap and very expensive scotch before served by people who make over a million dollars a year and this Lag 16 brings your senses to life. People seem to love it or hate it. Having never had a strong Islay before, the initial nose and taste shocked me but was never harsh..always smooth. After a couple sips I really started liking it and experiencing all the nuances.

13th February 2016

Usually I buy a bottle of Lagavulin 16 once a year and drink it within a few weeks or so. In the meantime I try all kinds of other whisky and whiskey. From all kinds of continents, though mainly from Scotland, I have to admit :) But the point is: every time I buy that bottle of Lag 16, I open the bottle, drink almost a 3rd of it within the first night and find myself asking: why buy anything else?

There was a period when I kind of resented or felt sinful about this whisky, because of its added color. But in the end, I just gave in to the perfection on the palate. I'm being honest to myself: I enjoy drinking this whisky a LOT. And I can still say, without any shame or whatsoever: Lagavulin 16 still is my favourite whisky for enjoyment and there's nothing I can do about it.

11th February 2016

One of the most complex whiskys you'll find. Tasting notes here are spot on. Anyone here that finds it at all disagreeable or sub-par can send their partially used bottle directly to me free of charge.

11th February 2016

I wish I took the time to read the reviews before I dropped $90 on a bottle. The first thing I noticed was it smelled very strongly of plastic and formaldehyde and to no surprise that's exactly how it tasted. I let it air in the glass for a while and still tastes as bad as the first sip. As it sat next to me my girl complains that it stunk terribly of cigarettes every time she walked past.

I truly wonder if it's my pallet that doesn't agree with it as another has comment or if it's a bad batch or bottle. My guess is it's my pallet because although my girl and I both hated the smell we differed greatly as to what that it's smelt like.

I will say although it is the worst scotch I've ever tasted it was one of the smoothest.

11th February 2016

Like a lot of people here I wanted to believe I was going to taste a wonderful rich robust Dram. Unfortunately this is not what I got. There is smoke, there is peat, but there is no thickness or robustness in it at all. Even the smoke and peat tastes quickly disappear from the mouth and you are left only with iodine. I am afraid to say I will also have a hard time drinking this Whisky, and I guess I will have to, because I would never offer it to a friend. Overall you have the impression that its not a well balanced Dram.

8th February 2016

This was one amazing experience. Early on .. if you rush the nose or the taste it hits a little too hard with the upfront smoke and you lose some of the spice and sweet layers that accompany it. Waiting a bit after your pour, and then enjoying the nose, waiting a bit more then taking a sip, really makes a difference. Overall.. what a scotch.. encompasses so many flavors with so many incredible "essences" of sherry, smoke, vanilla, and peat. Bravo.

7th February 2016

Nose- Intense burnt wood, campfire, touch of oak in there somewhere, and spice. Mostly smoke.
Palate - Oily viscous and peaty smoke. First chew - spice - faint cinnamon and burnt sugar, mostly oak wood, dry, dry wood and smoke.
Finish - Spice, burnt vanilla and burnt brown sugar, lastly campfire.
This is one of the smokiest Scotches I have ever sampled. I like it a lot but I dont pick up on the Lapsang Souchong tea. I love toasted teas. I don't get that here. To me its a tad 2-demensional. Scotch is very subjective to the drinker. This one doesn't call to me. I prefer the Laphroiag 10 year old. I still give it a 4. Its a great dram. This whisky will destroy your tastebuds. Drink this at the end of your night. You will taste campfire for at least 4 hours afterwards.

1st February 2016

I am a huge lover of all things scotch and Lagauvulin is in my top 2 or 3 but I could not drink it all the time if I'm feeling like a nice strong scotch it is my go-to.
If I feel like something a little more smooth then Oban 14year single malt is the one.
If Lagavulin

29th January 2016

I have always enjoyed Speyside Scotches the most because that's just always been my preference. A friend recently told me this was one of the best Scotches he's ever had. So before I tried it of course I was skeptical. However, I must say I was blown away when I had this! Never enjoyed peaty Scotch but this is truly exceptional. True world-class quality

26th January 2016

This was such a smooth tasting smokey scotch, literally could have drank this all night.

24th January 2016

I didn't like Scotch until I was introduced to Lagavulin by a coworker, God bless him. I've tried other Islays, and they're largely OK save for one little five year old that may turn out to be drinkable with another ten years or so in the cask. But I digress. There is no substitute; there is no equal. If you're going to drink Scotch, do it right.

23rd January 2016

Well, I have read the reviews and all I have to say is this is the Scotch that walks into the room and says piss off ya Beta males, I'm here and I'm SMOKIN'. It IS an acquired taste, it IS a love it or leave it; hopefully you leave it for the benefit of all the lovers of it. All I can say, is you walk up to the door to the reception of this marvelous home of Scotch and it's like your grandparents old house in the Orkney's. You are greeted by Mrs. Doubt-fire. In a wee whisper she takes you into her dining room ( taste room ) with Oak clad walls tastefully plaqued with awards and citations. On a long wood buffet sits bottles you only dream of. There is no watchful eye, but elegant and generous pouring of what ever you request, the age deep into the late seventies if you like. I try the Lag ga voo lin 18. Gold. Elixir of kilted Gods. I will not effuse winded descriptions of exotic teas and creosoted seal flippers, I'll leave that to the malthead Cryptographers. So........ in a wee brogue voice, the grace and manners that your gran used to have, she asks if you enjoyed it ? Like asking a 16 year old what he thought of their first sexual experience ! My wife drags me away, and God bless her, ranks that as the best she has had, including the trip to Oban, Spyside, as far south as Bladnoch and Glenkinchie as far north as Scapa. This is the peat. This is liquid earth. This is home. This is what keeps you from killing yourself on a stark and desolate landscape. Now the 16 - lovely. And as a Scot, when Costco in Kona had it on every Christmas for $46.00 a bottle, cases disappeared; much to the pleasure of my friends and family.........and every once and a while, a newbee screws their face and scowls at the " turpentine and burnt floor wax " I serve them. I smile, non judgmental, and think of Brussell Sprouts, Cigars and Blue Cheese. So, have a taste, and hopefully you'll get kicked in the nose and mouth and say.........that was the best Lay............. ga vul in ........... I ever had........... and one of the best Scotches ever.

19th January 2016

I don't understand complainers here. My personal favorite. Just ought a new bottle and it it one of the best whiskey especially for this price. Enjoying every moment of it. It is smooth with tasty cherry ending. The smokiness is rich and full but still not overwhelming the overall taste. It is always a best buy for me!

15th January 2016

Berry good aroma this whiskey has just become number one of my list

14th January 2016

The only way would taste better would be if I was wearing a smoking jacket as I peer out of the window from my study cussing out the snow.

14th January 2016

I have yet to drink anything better. I can get lost in the simple smell of this beautiful whisky before I even start drinking it. However, I have served it to many friends who cringed after a first sip and declared politely that it wasn't for them. It's best to let them smell the whisky first and decide if they even want to try a sip before serving them a more generous portion. This is one whisky you either love or hate.

12th January 2016

I just received a bottle for my 40th anniversary and it suits perfectly with this new phase of my life !!
Just perfect.

11th January 2016

Whisky king. Best of the best. Islay goodness.

9th January 2016

This stuff gives me immediate heartburn that gets worse with each sip. The smokiness is great, but the bottle I got is far from smooth. As this is my first experience with Lagavulin 16, it may need time to grow on me. For now it gets 2 stars because i didn't have to pay $100 for this bottle.

6th January 2016

A good friend gave me this bottle, having decided it wasn't to his taste. I'm so glad he did that.

Pungent, and powerful to both the nose and the tongue. Smoke, GLORIOUS smoke. I understand we all have differing tastes, but this was the most amazing taste of whisky I've ever had. My go-to dram has always been the simple, yet delicious, Glenlivet 15 French Oak. I didn't realize what I was missing in the Islay malts. Well, I'm catching on, and now have a new hobby sampling these lovely, flavorful whiskies.

THANK YOU TINY ISLAND!!!

5th January 2016

Not kidding, tastes great when it's freshly popped open, and for a day or two after..... but then it all goes wrong and not only does the sherry finishing seem to disappear but also the minerally peat edge..... Something is terribly wrong with Laga 16..... can any whisky explain this? That's the last bottle of this formerly great whisky I will ever buy..... So unless you're gonna polish off the bottle in one night with your mates, think again...

3rd January 2016

Needs to be in a locked safe with the combination only known by my wife so she can ration out to prevent me from draining the bottle at one sitting. Fantastic flavors and complexity with the Islay peat woven throughout.

3rd January 2016

Brutal crap!!!!

1st January 2016

One of the best single malts out there, worth every penny!

1st January 2016

I sniffed before I sipped, and commented that the smell reminded me of my doctor's office. One taste told me it's not to my liking, and the Tasting Notes above explained the medicinal smell: iodine! However, from the many 5-star reviews many find it wonderful. Just be sure to try a sample before investing $60 in a bottle - and don't give it as a gift to someone who hasn't tasted it.

31st December 2015

This is really great stuff; huge nose full of peat smoke, whiffs of brine and sweet oak and a hint of sherry, and a dozen other discreet but cohesive hints. Then there is the explosive palate, which I'm not even going to pretend I have fully explored. The finish is probably the biggest I've ever experienced. You'll blow through half a bottle just exploring the nose on this.

It's so good that even at 90 USD a bottle, it seems like a great value.

30th December 2015

Just got a bottle for Christmas and I just savour every drop!! Wonderful lingering after taste....what a treat. I'm hooked!!

30th December 2015

My girl surprised me with the best whiskey I've ever had. Word to Ron Swanson. Even smelling it can make you intoxicated!

27th December 2015

Disappointing, rather flat and one dimensional, with a somewhat unpleasant aftertaste. Makes me pine for my Laphroig.

26th December 2015

Got this for my birthday. It is a spectacular Scotch!

25th December 2015

Got given my first ever bottle today for christmas. I think if I had tried this 2 years ago when I first started exploring whisky I would not have liked it but now all I can say is WOW this is the one I have been looking for. Absolutely magnificent.

25th December 2015

Omg, this whiskey bar far is the best, its the first whiskey i can literally drink like a glass f wine, no water, no ice and no carbonated water... It is so rich and smooth, doesnt burn when you swallow... The flavors are amazing! Oak, leather and smokey flavors... I cant describe the experience, all i can say is that now im a lagavulin for life....

25th December 2015

I tried this whiskey many years ago and it's my best by far, sat with a lovely glass of Lagavulin next to a raging log fire to round a perfect evening off

24th December 2015

The Cognac of whiskeys!
A real gem, tastes of bonfire, absolutely outstanding if you're a fan of the Islay whiskeys.
Not as smokey as the Ardbeg in my opinion, slightly sweeter as well.

23rd December 2015

Out of respect for Ron I went ahead and bought some and unfortunately I thought it was awful, not far from the paint thinner comment of another person on this thread.
Ron and I may agree on libertarianism but definitely not on scotch.

15th December 2015

Not a go out and buy,actually it's does nothing for me

12th December 2015

Well it has smoke yeah.. But Laphroaig tastes better :/

8th December 2015

This was my first islay I ever tried. At first wasn't really sure what to think of it didn't taste like any other scotch I've had before so didn't like it so much. As I have become a more seasoned scotch drinker I've become a peat head and when I tried this again I knew I'd be drinking it as long as I lived. Initial flavor is like that first cigarette you had in high school dangerous yet delightful then comes a wave of black tea and seaweed followed by black pepper and peat smoke. Epic... it really does take you to the coast of islay. And to anyone who didn't like this try it again and again and again and eventually you will find yourself craving it. This ,laphroaig triple wood and ardbeg uigaedail are the 3 best scotches out there right now and will always be a part of my collection. The Sugarbear

5th December 2015

It's the only whisky you'll ever need. Tastes like a bonfire at the beach on a cold windy night.

5th December 2015

I so want to love this great looking scotch, however i have to agree with some of the people that are posting low scores on this scotch. the plastic metallic smell is so overpowering for me i cannot finish my bottle. i love macallan 12 and blue label, but this i cant drink. im wondering if its certain pallets that get this plastic/metal smell or if its certain batches, but this was very disappointing. is anyone else who is an experienced scotch taster finding the same thing?

3rd December 2015

Awesome whisky this is! My first Islay but wow I like it! Nice colour, thick and oily on the tongue. The smoke is great, not cigarish but like barbeque flavoured chips. Long smoky finish, very well balanced.

2nd December 2015

Got a bottle for my birthday. Tastes of heaven! Those who've never walked through NW Ireland in the wintertime probably can't understand the peaty smell/taste. Earthy, luxurious!

29th November 2015

You need a tolerance for iodine to enjoy this. And a mouthful of cigar smoke. De gustibus non est disputandum.

28th November 2015

As a multi generation scotch family everyone has a favorite. As far as bottles under a hundred dollars we all agree on this one. Truly a smokey scotch and may not be for amateur scotch enthusiasts though.

25th November 2015

Absolutely outstanding whiskey.
An absolute must try. Up there with my other favourite whiskey, Bowmore 17 year.
Thick, smooth and smokey.
If you like bowmore, laphroignore and ardbeg then you will live this.

24th November 2015

Having no idea what single malts were about, I had my Scotish barkeep line up his favorites so I could sample them without knowing anything about them (price, location, type, reputation, etc.). After several hours, I finally got to Lagavulin and I liked it best hands down. It is now my standard for comparison to any other scotch ~ there are others that are great, but for the price ~ it's still my favorite!

20th November 2015

This scotch has a certain uniqueness that others simply don't possess. This scotch is certainly smokey and slightly sweet, but the peatiness brings all the flavors together. Take a sip (without ice) and let it sit on your tongue for 10-15 seconds, swallow, and breathe slowly. You'll know exactly what I'm talking about.....

Cheers

15th November 2015

Best peated whisky ever. Always have in my bar.

14th November 2015

I really struggle with the negative reviews of this, and many other Islay malts. The intrinsic character of Islay malts lies in its peated barley. This imparts notes of chemical cleaners, iodine and even formaldehyde, and varying levels of smoke. This smoke can be medicinal or bonfire, depending on cask influence and peat ppm levels. With that said, I would recommend working up to a malt of this strong character. Try some Speysiders, or even a Bowmore or Bunnahabhain before taking this on. As for my review, and I should say I've had exactly ONE dram from my bottle, I was hoping for more. It's not bad at all, in fact I think it's got a lot to offer, but I'm finding it a bit uninspired. The coat lines and legs are gorgeous.
Nose: roiling peat smoke, beautiful barley sugar, vanilla and soft oak
Palate: full and oily, creamy even. coats the tongue. Phenolic smoke leading into a touch of dried dark fruit, vanilla and more of that soft oak
Finish: it starts slow, with sweet raisin, fig and dates and then fell a bit flat on me. After a bit of time, the smoke crept back in
Closing Thoughts: this is a fine malt, but for me, the lack of complexity left me wanting. I've got to try the Distiller's Edition.

31st October 2015

Nose - new asphalt, antiseptic ointment, ripe apples. With water new teabags and candy apple. Flavour: amaretti biscuits fruitcake fruit, sweet almond. With water musk melon marzipan and malted milk. Finish: almandine honey menthol and Ben-gay. Great Halloween malt! Mark from WhiskyWhistle

30th October 2015

Have been drinking Lagavulin for over 20 years. Occasionally sample something else like Macallan, Glenfeddich, Glenmorangie, Talisker, Balvenie, etc. Many are good, but none have the bold, smokey satisfying flavor of Lagavulin

26th October 2015

The smoked aroma of Lagavulin takes away the taste of liquor in your palate and after three doubles of it you start feeling as it you have millions of dollars. The morning after is a refreshing one because you want to eat your porridge before breakfast, no hangovers at all.

15th October 2015

Colour:
My Glencairn nosing glass showed an almost greenish hue to the dark amber gold.

Nose:
Massive peat grips you by the face then slaps you. The other reviews that describe the smell of Band Aids are spot-on. Lapsang Souchon tea. So much depth and intensity of aroma. Incredible on the olfactory senses but balanced by a sweet creamy smoothness and slightly sherried nose.

Body:
Full bodied and oily.

Palate:
Peat overdose, smoke, iodine, sea salt, a hint of burnt fruit. Subtle sweetness hidden behind a veil of more peat and smoke. If you can handle its undiluted intensity you'll find a whiskey like few others. The peat and smoke isn't of the same ashtray like intensity of other peated single malts and the sherry aspect helps balance it and gives it a smoothness unlike any other single malt I've tasted. Incredible.

Finish:
The longest but most pleasing finish. Should you be foolish enough to over-indulge you'll still be tasting it the morning after, hopefully!

The first Islay I tried. I feel it's best described as creamy, oily, liquid smoke. Not cheap by any means but utterly sublime. I once thought it was only bettered by Laphroaig Quarter Cask. Having returned to it I feel it's more subtle, sherried quality and smoothness over QC give it the top spot. Incredible stuff and for me the greatest whisky I've had so far on this incredible journey.

2nd October 2015

I'll start by saying that I'm a Glenlivet man. My Lagavulin 16 experience was very bad. My first thought was "paint thinner"- simply impossible to drink. I've only had the problem once before with a sample bottle of Islay whisky. I've read the reviews, and your descriptions of "smokey" and "woody" are accurate. I tried another sip without ice and it went down, but it's going to take some time before I acquire a taste for it.

27th September 2015

Being a scotch lover, Lagavulin is great. So is all scotch at this level of quality. I enjoy variety, even 6 year old Famous Grouse. However, I do drink Lagavulin more often than others.

21st September 2015

But after a few days of sampling it my opinion has changed. I hit it at a 1/2 shot per night, even at $100 a bottle its practically a bargain. A lot of people mention the woody notes but theres more to it. The kick has its own complexities that carry an evolving profile as it settles on the pallet. I love it. I expect the bottle to continue to evolve as I drink it over time, a rare pleasure.

14th September 2015

Some morons actually drinks this with ice. Correct temperature is everything with a single malt, a bit too high or low and it changes character.

Still my favorite btw, a winter whisky.

1st September 2015

Ok I'm only here because Ron Swanson recommended this

31st August 2015

I received my first bottle of Lagavulin 16 as a gift from some of my members! I have always enjoyed the Glen 12 as my usual drink. NO MORE! Your 16 year old scotch has a new best friend, I love the mellow smokey flavor that stays with you long after the drink. My favorite scotch of all.

22nd August 2015

If you like this one you should get your hands on a bottle of the cask-strength Lagavulin. I picked up one at Marty's in Newton MA when on a business trip there 4-5 years ago and it is spectacular. (A bit pricey though!)

this has been my favorite malt for years although I got a bottle of cask strength old-stock from Ardbeg a few years ago that came pretty damned close.

21st August 2015

Title speaks for it self. Simply astonishing how well rounded this single malt is. If I could afford a closet full of this I would, always have one around. If I had one item to bring on a desert island, it would be this bottle.

20th August 2015

Somebody reviewed this single malt and called it undrinkable and unquaffable. Well of coz its undrinkable if you quaff it. this whisky is to be savoured. It's complex but interesting. I don't pretend to taste the myriads of flavours the experienced drinkers mention. I just know that this is one good whisky to be savoured alone or with a few good friends and you'll find peace on earth even if it's temporary.

28th July 2015

Because the are from Texas !!

I am enjoying both the Lagavulin-16 and the Laphraoig-18. I have chronic sinus issues so I miss some of the nose and aroma. But I do get the aftertaste and these are very smooth to me.

22nd July 2015

I had this at Chicago Restaurant in Marietta, Georgia. GREAT!!!!! If you like a "smokey scotch" then you will love this one!!!!!!!!!!!!!

11th July 2015

...but the MOM description seems a bit outdated. The current bottlings actually come across as s bit thin for a 16, and far from the most powerful Islay on the nose. That said, it's beautiful and the bottle gets better as the level descends below the shoulders. The sherry influence - for my tastes - is just about perfect, eliminating entirely the sulphurous pitfalls of many such finishings. But the price!...at $90-$100 in the Carolinas, it's not practical for 'everyday' enjoyment. And...for me the power and glory of Lagavulin resides in the 12 year which unfortunately has crept to $130ish most places.

Here's a tip to enjoy them both: Pour off 1/2 of the 16 and add 1-2 tablespoons of the 12, or for the risk adverse, pour 6 ounces into an empty 1/2 pint and add 3/4 tbs. Don't dare call yourself a Lagavulin freak unless you try this...add a little of the 12 or 16 as needed to reach your optimum profile. For times when the staid, diplomatic beauty of the 16 could use a nudge of invigoration, you can now date her red-headed sister. She'll even encourage you - hip, hip!

At the $65ish price in the DC area, picking up a case there makes the 16 ia stone-cold winner and currently the best standard bottling of any distillery, IMO.

9th July 2015

The only real mans drink, clear alcohols are for rich women on diets

8th July 2015

This is not really a review, I'm just completely baffled by one of the reviews on this page - why the fuck would anybody want to mix a $60-80 bottle of Islay malt with coke? Its like getting a fine piece of toro and dipping in ranch dressing.

As far as the drink itself, its a masterpiece, IF Islay is your thing. I know many seasoned scotch drinkers that can't palate anything from Islay. I've wasted many fine drams on such drinkers :).

4th July 2015

I read every single review on here before purchasing a bottle. My initial though after opening the bottle was, "holy s*it"!! The flavor is flavor and texture is beyond belief. I was an Oban 14 drinker, but no longer. A great scotch from start to finish. Buy it!!

30th June 2015

The first thing you smell is pure smoke. The first thing you taste is... pure smoke. At first I was pretty disappointed in this malt because of it's reputation and price. All I got was smoke and nothing else. However after leaving it in the glass for about 15-20 min it began to release a great deal of flavors and some added sweetness which makes it quite enjoyable. I personally don't add any water to it but I do let it sit and open up.

There is much more smoke than peat in this one which I really like (peat is good but after a little while the taste can be over powering in some scotch like bowmore 12 imo)

26th June 2015

there is no sherry casks used in the production of lagavulin 16yr old.the sweetness is due to the high grade bourbon cask being used.98% of this is for single malt,the rest for white horse blends.it's the best of the best anywhere in scotland period.i clean out my car engine with johnny walker red,i did'nt
know you drank it. stupid american.

24th June 2015

One of the first single malts I'd tasted and it was such an eyeopener. Maybe not the best introductory whisky for newbies, but for me it worked. Lovely stuff of smoke and sweetness, always having a bottle of this around (together with the Glendronach 15 :D )

18th June 2015

I've been drinking Lagavulin for a while now and I'm never disappointed. However the recent bottle that I cracked open just tastes flat. There is no peaty smoke to it nor that seaweed iodine taste that I liked. This one feels likes its a completely different whiskey and not a Lagavulin at all. I can taste the vanilla but then an under current of coconut. It's a 2014 batch, not sure if this a bad bottled year?

12th June 2015

Absolutely love the complexity of this scotch.

12th June 2015

I have been drinking Lagavulin 16 for almost 10 years. I have a few in the cabinet like: Highland Park, Jura and Caol Ila but my favorite of all is Lagavulin. Great with a single ice cube, single drop of water or neat. It does not matter.

8th June 2015

I had high expectations about this malt ... and I must say , the widely exceeded . Of course who believes otherwise is not used to a taste with a complex of sensations construction. Not a whiskey for inexperienced rookies.

6th June 2015

I could not taste anything besides gasoline and paint thinner. I wished desperately to enjoy it, though.

2nd June 2015

Prior to experiencing Lagavulin 16, I only enjoyed certain Islays. A lot of them simply seemed to pungent and overbearing for my palate. But once I came to try this, I was totally hooked not only on this particular Islay, but to others as well. Another reviewer described it as a "great entry-level Islay," and I would say that is a fair description. Yet, even though I've moved on to, and have grown to love, many others, I still find myself coming back to this.

2nd June 2015

The smokey nose and smooth burnt finish make this scotch a winner for me. Although in the upper price realm, I feel for a 16YO Single it still represents a solid buy.
We always keep a bottle on hand.
And yes, it goes quite nicely with a fine robusto.

23rd May 2015

Lagavulin 12 cask strength is much better. In Lagavulin 16, woody note overpowers everything else. Still good whisky, but legend? Try Springbank 12 cas strenght to taste what true legend in making is.

21st May 2015

What can I say that hasn't been said. Simply put this is the best entry level Islay whisky period. It's perfect. If you don't love it go back to your sherry bombs!

20th May 2015

If God would have made a better Islay Single Malt he would have kept it for Himself!

19th May 2015

There is definitely something unique about Lagavulin its hard to mistake for anything else. I really don't think the nose is "stunning" as the tasting notes suggest unless it's about the pungency of the peat, in which case .. maybe - although there are more pungent peaty whiskies about. There is a dryness to the peat and it is really phenolic and smoky. I also don't agree that its "thick" maybe times have moved on. Its potent but it's also only 43% which limits the concentration of flavour. For me this is more the middle ground but not in price. Given the price and what is on offer its definitely more of a myth than a legend for me. The finish is quite wishy washy i really do dispute that it is long, theres a bit of peat and a slight pepperiness but compared to other peaty whiskies its lacking, and its much more expensive. Its good but not great.

19th May 2015

when your palate begins to develop you really will appreciate what a fantastic and legendry whisky this really is.

14th May 2015

Expected nice smooth "oily" taste, instead horrible taste similar to Fernet? Strong herby taste.

13th May 2015

was expecting a very good scotch due to almost all 5 star reviews here but the hard iodine taste overpowers everything else and makes it undrinkable for me :(

10th May 2015

I'm usually not a big fan of Islay whisky but I'll make an exception for lagavulin. The nose alone is worth the price of the bottle, and the taste and finish have a "roundness" to them that I find hard to find in other Islay whiskies.

3rd May 2015

I have yet to find such an extinguish taste as I have found in the Lagavulin. It is available in every Vinmonopol (category 3 and upwards at least) in Norway.

2nd May 2015

Knew it was something special at the first drink. Smokey and peaty to start with a long lingering finish… You simply can't have just one dram. Lagavulin-16 is a staple in my home, I'm never without.

28th April 2015

I have a few whiskeys in my collection and i like them all, but if i had to drink only one forevermore, it would be Lagavulin 16.

First bottle was given to me as a gift by my other half. We thought we woudld have an occasional glass, and it would be there for years with many of the other spirits we have in the house but it was gone after 3 weeks.

Its more than i would usually spend, but as we enjoyed it so much i have vowed to never be without a bottle and so have purchased a few more.

Of all the peated whiskeys its easily the most balanced. The peat is strong, but not overpowering like it so often is in these peated whiskeys. it makes itself known, but gets out of the way for the smooth flavours to come through, and boy is it smooth.
The hint of iodine is there towards the end but is complementary rather than offputting, and just adds to the character of this drink.

For me, as with most whiskeys its best at room temperature with literally " a drop" of water to balance it all out.

You need to try this at least once in your life. if peated whiskeys are your thing, i struggle to see how it cant become a favourite.

27th April 2015

Such a wonderful scotch to drink with a good book in front of a fireplace on a snowy day....

27th April 2015

I am a fan of Talisker 10 but this scotch raises the bar. Smooth with a magical blend of flavors and complexity.

23rd April 2015

To the boy that thought he opened a bottle of paint thinner...you should stick to drinking Wild Turkey or perhaps Southern Comfort. With that said to those of you that are looking for a Peaty/Smoky finish, this is for you. The quality and long finish is second to none! This is private stock material!

21st April 2015

A a rule I don't drink, but I will always break the drought with a fine whiskey. I have one bottle stashed on my boat and that is Lagavulin.

18th April 2015

I hear it all the time; add a few drops of water or a single cube to get the full spectrum of flavors. In the past I dutifully tried every new whisky straight and then with additions. Without exception I ended up wishing I had not added anything, so now, I don't. I'm drinking L16 right now. Superb!

16th April 2015

As a driver in the Highlands I deliver to a lot of these distillery.the 16 is certainly very good, if you like the peaty ones, also try Ledaig,Laphroaig, glenmorangie if you like the peaty ones.Talisker, bunnahabhain,Bowmore and Highland park and antiquary great too.

15th April 2015

Spent an evening smoking cigars and sipping this EXCELLENT scotch with some friends I hadn't seen in a long while. Heartily recommended.

14th April 2015

I recomended to try lagavulin 12yo good as 16yo

13th April 2015

For me it started with that smokey peat and laughably I definitely got bacon, some back palet of fruit and the sherry notes come through nicely. I feel this one is lovely but not rich or bold enough for me. Aberlour a'bunadh and Nikka fr m the barrel have been my latest treats so maybe I have been used to bigger lately but I still feel it needs more.

13th April 2015

I love my Islay whiskies and this has taken the reins as the best I have had. The balance is perfect between all the elements and it is wonderfully smooth. I could smell this whisky all night.

13th April 2015

One of the best ones

11th April 2015

wonderfully rich and smokey, if I had to choose a whiksey that I have to drink for the rest of my life this would be the one.

9th April 2015

First experience with an Islay. Found it to be very distinctive and rich. Wonderful peaty-smoke nose and a burst of flavor on the first sip. Definitely will imbibe again in the near future.

7th April 2015

Just received a bottle for my birthday. Wow what an experience, I have dabbled a bit from laphroaig to macallens. Lagavulin is incredible, a slow draw and a tear in my eye. Perfect.

6th April 2015

Simply the best…and no, Amrut Fusion, Bowmore and even Blue are not as good

My 25 year old son brought a bottle of Lagavulin 16 to a recent gathering of his college friends…now all young professionals. After tasting, amazed, they asked, "Why do you have a scotch like this?" His response: "Why DON'T you have a scotch like this?"

1st April 2015

Not as peaty as Laphroaig. Love the fruit, oak n peat combination.. Right now my favourite.

31st March 2015

Beautiful smokey taste with a hot after bite. Great whiskey for a novice and seasoned professional. Fantastic.

29th March 2015

Was looking forward to trying my bottle of Lagavulin 16 the other night, 1 oz over ice and thought I opened paint thinner by mistake. Found it to be undrinkable, and was glad the Liqour store took the opened bottle back. I guess the smokey plastic taste is acceptable to a lot of people. Will stick with my Glenlivet and Macallan

29th March 2015

I enjoy most of the Island Malts, but Lagavulin although slightly more expensive is a nice one to bring to the table, I like the bottle, label, dark colour and of course the taste, served only with ice. One to share with people who have an appreciative pallette.

27th March 2015

The smell is a bit overpowering, but absolutely delicious.

25th March 2015

this stuff is the milk of the gods. it's just a masterpeace.

24th March 2015

This is a great wiskey--- Amrut fusion an India whiskey is its equal--- although not a Scotch it has all the charteristics of one and half of the barley is imported from Scotland ----trust me their both great

23rd March 2015

Is this guy kidding? The only "mix" I would have with this whiskey or any other in it's class is a little bit of high quality water. Experienced drinker, my ass. I've only been getting into single malts for a few years now and even I know better than that. Mix with coke? That's insane. No wonder he doesn't like it.

22nd March 2015

I was stationed at Holy Loch, Scotland in the early 1980's when I was in the Navy. I now regret that I did not enjoy the many,many excellent whiskies that are produced in that beautiful land of my ancestors. But, I was just a stupid kid and only new about JWR and Black and the only thing the locals seem to know about was The Famous Grouse. YUCK!
The difference between TFG and Lagavulin is like comparing lead and gold. My only regret is that it took me almost 30 years to discover that. Better late than never. Cheers.

22nd March 2015

Solid 4.5 star rating!

19th March 2015

I just received a bottle along with a few others in an online purchase. I got it at a steal for $62. Normally this whisky sells for $90 plus tax at the local discount liquor super store. I'm here to tell you that this is one of the best buys I've ever made in my 57 years on Earth! What a superb whisky! Truly remarkable. I'm just an aspiring Scotch lover and don't have the sophistication of describing in detail the many sensations I had when tasting this fine whisky, but I know what I like and I REALLY like this! At this price I'm going to guy a case of this while it is still on sale! This is definitely in my TOP 5 along with Glenfarclas (all years) Talisker 10, Oban 14, and Tomatin 18. Cheers!

19th March 2015

I dont understand why I dont like Lagavulin. My favorite whiskys are Ardbeg, Kilchoman, Laphroiag, Arran and Bowmore. Im a Islay guy. Ive tried Lagavulin 16 and 12, even the double matured sherry version. Do not like any of them. Full bodied ppl say...??
The smoke is there...and its the right Islay trademark smoke. But thats it really. Bhind the smoke I get some faint sweet flavour...but it taste kinda plastic/aspartame sweet.

18th March 2015

When it comes to Eastern Wisdom this is as far east as I go. -Man

18th March 2015

As with many Scotch drinkers, I started with the Speysides and Highlands. Enjoyed them immensely but craving ever more flavors moved on the the Islays. Now there is no going back. Nothing else will do. I keep Bowmore 18 and Ardbeg Uigeadail on the shelf, but find myself going for the Lagavulin 16 time after time. A masterpiece!

10th March 2015

Yes this is the stuff all good things are made of. Advice to all who try this amazing nectar...don't have a different whisky within weeks of taking Lagavulin...you will feel let down..nothing compares to Lagavulin 16.

6th March 2015

Wanted this for a long time, best single malt From Islay.

5th March 2015

Tried this for the first time last night. Was not prepared for the smokey peat. To me it initially tasted like I was trying to drink liquified pipe tobacco. after a little while, I adjusted, perhaps its just my pallet I am so used to and love my Glenlivet. I'll give it another go before I pass judgment.

28th February 2015

I've been a scotch lover since I was in college (and that was a long time ago); this is the best in my opinion. However, it is smokey and very peatey, so has an interesting flavor which to some may take a while to get accustomed to, and appreciate. But, once you experience it, be advised, because you will probably be addicted.

20th February 2015

tried this monster at a whisky bar recently, my wife had a BBQ bacon cheeseburger and I had a dram of Lagavulin. I felt like we probably had the same experience, very smoky nose, with strong bacon and BBQ notes coming through. Finish was the iconic seaweed/iodine Islay finish, I will now keep a bottle of this in my collection at all times.

19th February 2015

I have read a few negative reviews on here and I respect that everyone has their own tastes and opinions. However, if you do not like this bottle you simply do not like Scotch. I wouldn't comment on rum or Taylor Swift's new album because I know I would dislike all versions. If you like Scotch, this is worth trying.

14th February 2015

I have to say the first taste I was thinking someone handed me a glass of Jonny Walker Blue. More peaty and smokey though and a bit more of a after taste due to the smokey flavor. All in all definitely worth a try

7th February 2015

I would hear reviews about "peaty" & "smoky" whiskies and would be scared yet excited to know if I would like this type of whisky or not. This bottle was my introduction and I am by far pleased with the taste. It held my hand to understand completely now what reviewers are talking about when they speak about "smoke" and how it is such a pleasant flavor when tasting other notes in whisky. I must admit that for the quality you are getting within this price range is absolutely fantastic. I think this bottle just became a signature staple on my shelf.

6th February 2015

I Love that this is made by Diageo

31st January 2015

I saw this at a liquor store in Denver tonight. It was priced at $42.00.
Since I didn't know this scotch I opted for a bottle of cognac.
I think I'll go back and get one after reading all these reviews.

24th January 2015

This is easily one of the most enjoyable single malts I have had the pleasure of drinking. From Islay, this is a smokey pete whiskey with a great finish. One of the best, but a little on the expensive side for the alcohol content. Well worth the money though and a great treat.

23rd January 2015

This whisky is just not quaffable. Smells like plastic - tastes like I imagine a vinyl car seat would taste if it were ground up and fermented in water.

22nd January 2015

For the money one of the best ive had by far!

16th January 2015

This is simply the best of the best in my choice of single malt whiskey.

13th January 2015

I am fairly new to whisky. Started with a view mini's. At first, the peated whisky's made me kind of sick, but I grew on it. Now I think the smoky ones are the best. The smokier, the better. I absolutely adore it. I didn't expect that to happen. Ardbeg, Connemara, Caol Ila, very very nice drams. But this one, the Lagavulin, is the best of them all for now. I even closed my eyes when I tasted this whisky. It's delicious. Wow.

8th January 2015

I was given a bottle for Christmas and it has such a strong iodine that it is non-drinkable. With compost since I do not drink iodine I can see no reason why to try to drink a good scotch that has such a bad aftertaste. I was told that heavy cigar smokers love this product. not being a cigar smoker I wonder if all of their taste buds are burned off.

6th January 2015

Just grand. Love my kids for their good taste.

5th January 2015

My first taste of this nectar of the gods made me feel like the barrel has washed ashore and stayed in a cave for a long time. Beautiful peat smoke and the essence of the sea with no salt, my favorite.

2nd January 2015

My son presented this to me for Christmas and what a celebration! After dinner many of us at the table put the finishing touches on a great meal with this fantastic scotch. It's all about the smokey bass, thanks Remy!!!

28th December 2014

Enjoyed it on Christmas Eve after a great meal.

26th December 2014

When you come across this drop all you can do is Respect the Scotch.

25th December 2014

Very smooth, peaty, but it leaves something to be desired on the finish. I ended up buying a 2nd bottle after the first just to make sure I wasn't missing anything, and it was consistent with the first. Just doesn't do it for me entirely. The strange thing is it did leave me with some desire for it after the fact and I did go back for that 2nd bottle. There is something hidden there I may just not have identified. After the 2nd bottle though, I'm still scratching my head trying to figure it out and I think the desire may have just been the missing components I was looking for that just were not there with this whisky and hoping I would find. Overall not a bad whisky, but moving on.

21st December 2014

This is my favorite Islay. In my area it is pricey. What can I say perfection isn't cheap.

20th December 2014

Lagavulin 16 is easily the most beautifully crafted thing ever bottled. A distinct but not overwhelming peat flavor with notes of sea spray to begin. After a few sips the notes of caramel and (I am in the minority opinion with this but..) chocolate covered raisins come through. I wish I can give it more than a 10-10 because that just doesn't seem good enough.

17th December 2014

For those who love it would probably give it 5 stars ... the first point it hits your nose ... the strong palette ... the lingering after taste ... would probably leave the people who enjoy this taste wanting more ...

unfortunately ... she is not a lady for me ... she smells like that ash smell when you go to the dentist and they drill your molars for cavity ... then it lingers within your mouth like a long been put out cigar ...

15th December 2014

Extremely smokey, yet remarkable smooth. The peat on nose on this sucker will nearly knock you out, and is overpowering. The taste is mesmerizing, with a sherry sweetness lingering on the palate with the finish. New favorite.

14th December 2014

I had a chance to sit down with a bottle last night. Truely a great Scotch. it got better and better with every mouthful.

12th December 2014

The nose is nothing special (your usual islay malt smoke peaty smell) the palate is a vast improvement. However, the finish is without a doubt one of best I have ever tasted. Very few world whiskies will have you going to bed dreaming of waking up with the same taste still in your mouth as much as this will. It is a must try

8th December 2014

I accept that it's not as good as it used to be but it is still without a doubt the best entry level whisky on the market and for the price it is definitely a bit of a steal, I've had more expensive whisky that were not as good as this but still, in my opinion, were still worth the price I paid. It's far from the finished product but if you get the chance you have to give it a try

8th December 2014

Hauntingly brilliant taste. Smooth, smoky peat, and sherry flavor. Great after taste that lingers for a long time where the hints of vanilla comes through. I can still taste it. I would never mix anything with this outstanding single malt. Hands down my favorite Scotch.

27th November 2014

During My stay at twin farms, I wanted to try Scotch and knew about Glenlivet. to my surprise the attended ask me several questions about my spirit choices, after we exchanged notes he asked if would mind trying this, i gave it a try and never once looked back to want the Glenlivet. the smoke and peat is such a great blend. yes these are not for everyone's pallet, but if you like the rich smoke and peat. in a scotch that's meant to be drank neat this is perfect.

26th November 2014

The Irish would say, "Brilliant". But then they say that when I make correct change. Seriously, this is Nirvana for me. I've tried a number of others, many of which were fine Scotches, but that smokey, peaty richness just does me in. "Heaven, I'm in heaven..."

23rd November 2014

This is the best Scotch I have ever had

22nd November 2014

Doesn't get more complex and interesting for an experienced single-malt palate than Lag... If you aren't ready for something like this...that's OK - it takes some time wiht singles to appreciate something like this.

And if you are so fucking stupid that you would mix something as artistic and unique as Lagavulin with ANYTHING, you should be immediately euthanized. Beware the Mix...seriously? What a moron...anyone who talks about "mixers" on a single malt page is galactically stupid...

Spare us all from your stupidity...jump on a kitchen knife...stay away from these pages

20th November 2014

To the folks complaining that Lag is just too smoky--one person asks how to "mitigate the smoke"--this IS A SMOKY ISLAY scotch. You wouldn't go to one of the original meat market smokehouses in Lockhart, Texas, taste their brisket and then go up to the counter and ask them how to get rid of the smoke. You wouldn't call up the Cohiba factory and Cuba and ask them why the maduros you just got taste so...smoky. Here's how to "mitigate the smoke": give that bottle to someone who appreciates it, and enjoy your Chivas and your Tony Roma's ribs.

20th November 2014

Ignore Beware the Mix, he's been trolling on several whiskey threads with the same stuff: "doesn't mix well with my Doctor Pepper", "doesn't go so well with my lucozade" etc

20th November 2014

The lag 16 gives a peat smoke flavour so refined as to be a standard against which others are measured. A classic peated islay to be kept always on hand to teach of peat smoke pure and tasteful.

16th November 2014

Shared amongst brothers. Very well received. The most satisfying and tasty malt my under experienced palate has tasted. Should have bought 2 bottles.

8th November 2014

Nose is smoky, salty iodine, with subtle mint and citrus. Very smooth on the tongue, thick peat, smoky goodness. Long smooth smoky finish, ahhhh

8th November 2014

The show "Parks and Recreation" led me to want to try this whiskey, as one of the Iconic characters refuses to drink any whiskey besides this one, so I assumed it was a man's drink. The show was right. This is a great and powerful, smokey and flavorful whiskey. Definitely worth the price.

31st October 2014

An experienced drinker wouldn't dream of mixing a single malt with coke or anything for that matter especially the Lagavulin 16. Perhaps you are an experienced drinker of cheap whiskeys?

29th October 2014

Is this a joke?

"Experienced drinker"
"If like me you like to mix your whisky with coke"
"There are much better drams out there"

27th October 2014

Please be warned by an experienced drinker - this does not mix well at all. If like me you like to mix your whisky with coke, irn bru or lemon then this is not for you. There are much better drams out there.

26th October 2014

I've seen this Scotch described as "massively peaty"...whilst it's certainly peaty....it's not massive...not in the same league as Ardbeg or Laphroaig....but it's certainly very nice...spicy and rich and full of tatse...it's not amazing but a lovely scotch, and reasonably cheap..so try it.

23rd October 2014

First impressions: Caol Ila 12 but stronger. A little disappointed, even though I like Caol Ila 12. I was hoping for something bolder. On second taste, however, the spirit, as it often happens, came to life. Much more smoke on the nose and salt on the palate. As a huge bourbon drinker and a fan of every Islay I've had so far, it definitely ranks as one of the best. However, at the price it is, it should have a higher ABV (46-50%) and no chill-filtering. Price aside, it is great stuff.

19th October 2014

Amazing taste sip it and saviour but don't go near it if you are basic blended and water person. Enough said!

11th October 2014

Smoke all the way.. Not your every dram.

10th October 2014

Shared your gem with a gathering of 100+ US academics in London last week. Stunned by its potent aroma and unending smooth taste, L quickly became known as 'liquid smoke'. My task, should I accept it, is now to ship tasters and/or bottles to our next gathering in October 2015. All help appreciated!

6th October 2014

I had always been more partial to small batch bourbons than whiskey. Once I was offered a glass of Lagavulin 16, it was obvious the reason was because I had never had the right whiskey before. Delightful, bold complex taste that lingers. It has become my "adult beverage" of choice.

3rd October 2014

Mmm, the smell and taste take me to the Atlantic Ocean. Home. Salt and peat smoke on the nose. Big, rich mouthful. Spicy and peaty with a sherry influence. Vanilla and figs. Peat and smoke lasts for several minutes. This commands respect.

30th September 2014

Recent batches of Lagavulin 16 lack the sherry cask influence that was present even just a few years ago. It's still decent - just different, and less complex than it used to be without the sherry cask involvement.

29th September 2014

Прекрасный виски, один из САМЫХ любимых!!! Я вижу, предыдущий комментатор жалуется на взлёт цен на Lagavulin в США. Я не знаю сколько стоит он в Америке, но в Украине Lagavulin 16 стоит 1200 грн. - зарплата 2000 - 3000 грн. (это не описка) Так что братья американцы - не печальтесь, не только вам тяжело!

29th September 2014

Someone asked my recently; "what's your favourite whisky?", It's an impossible question, but if I had to answer, all things considered, it would be this, Lagavulin 16.

28th September 2014

Warning: -any positive review you may have seen about LV 16 is an absolute understatement. When Brian Cox says this one is his favorite, now I know why. I give it a 10 out of 10. It is hard to imagine a single malt getting any better.Delicious.!!!! Just the right balance of smoke(peat) , sweetness, complexity, zero burn. Magnificent. Even with recent price run ups in the US, it is worth it.

14th September 2014

In one word: GENIUS!
~jL

12th September 2014

If you like smoke and peat, with a hint of sweetness (sherry), you will love this! It has an outside, seaside savour to it. Don't listen to negative reviews. Can't imagine anyone who really appreciates good scotch not appreciating this. It is a favorite among many long-time scotch drinkers.

2nd September 2014

I must have been looking for like months before I found this totally awesome whisky. The USA of course makes the most epic whiskies but this is totally not bad. I would give it like 8 out of 10 and rate it as high as like a Jim Beam.
Big Jim - Kentucky

29th August 2014

Agreed, a mediocre Islay malt. Was great when I starting out in the world of single malts but somehow lacking now.

25th August 2014

This is a very smooth flavoursome scotch,but I find it so overwhelmingly smokey,so as to be undrinkable.Deeply disappointed. Can any one suggest how to mitigate the smokiness?

23rd August 2014

I've been desperate for a regular drinking scotch to have a few drams of on weeknights or quiet saturdays and I have found it. This is such a delicious whisky with just the right blend of sweetness and peat. It is just at the top end price wise of what I would consider to be affordable everyday whisky, but it is absolutely worth it.

20th August 2014

Few years ago this was magnificent malt, but not anymore. No it's just a mediocre Islay malt. So sad.

17th August 2014

i was hesitating to buy this, because of the sweetness. But don't worry at all i took the risk and it payed of big time! This is a very balanced whisky, i would recommend this to anyone who has Ardbeg, Caol ila and talisker.

8th August 2014

A smoky, rich, very smooth and balanced whisky. Highly recommended!
Peter

2nd August 2014

Hands down the best single malt. Sipping one after dinner makes the day complete.

30th July 2014

very tasty
will buy again
whoever makes this you have brought me back to the land of scotch

22nd July 2014

To the person who said women can't appreciate a good whisky, I'm a woman and this is my favourite. It's mellow, honey tasting, but not to sweet with some and vanilla. Words don't do this justice. It's nectar.

19th July 2014

I've been sipping on this whisky for a few hours now, trying out the flavours and letting it grow on me. When you put your nose to the glass, you get a smokiness that is truly beautiful. It's Lapsang Souchong, dark wood, strong, with the aromas of a warm fire or a burning cigar. The Lagavulin 16 is an instant favourite, and it is a whisky that will always be on my shelf. However, I do advise anyone who is new to single-malt whiskies to try something else, perhaps a speyside whisky before moving on to the islas, because the rich flavours of the Lagavulin will be lost on you. It's a whisky to be savoured and taken in little sips. A truly fantastic buy, and the beginning of a new love affair.

11th July 2014

My wife just bought me a bottle of this for Father's day and I was suitably impressed. Wonderful nose, great and clean finish. I am a big fan of peated scotch and smoky flavours. Its going to be difficult to not polish off this bottle quickly.

18th June 2014

Hi Guys,

Need your help. I know nothing about whiskeys, but reading these reviews I think this may be a good 30th birthday present for my fiance? opinions please xx

17th June 2014

I thought I wouldn't like the peated stuff after being put off a bit by Ardbeg's intensity but a glass of this a few days ago changed my mind completely. The peat was like a scaffold for the other flavors to dance around on. Great balance and loooong finish. Sweeter than I thought it would be, and smoky and coastal in the best ways possible. It stayed on my palate all night, a treat that was well worth the high price.

16th June 2014

As the title says...great raisin and fruit mixed with slight salty/medicinal but thick rolling smoke. Recent bottling I tried is not as oily or viscous as previous ones - something that Jim Murray also notes in his Whisky Bible 2014. Why I wonder? What a useless review below dated 9 June 2014. Really worth reading.....not.

12th June 2014

Yeah.. it's ok, I wouldn't punch the person who gifts this bottle to me, I just would not pay the price myself.
As with most whiskys, burns your mouth and numbs your palate. Drink enough of it and it doesn't matter.

9th June 2014

My son bought me a bottle for my birthday.i was always a Highland Park man but this stuff is incredible.Sweet smokey very complex.i agree with others that a touch of water opens it up.Wonderful!!

7th June 2014

I'm a big fan of Islay whisky's. Although i like this Lagavulin i found the nose to be not too complex and doesn't last very long on the tongue. It can be quite harsh to the uninitiated but i find a teaspoon of chilled Scottish spring water brings out the flavours better. It's not as smooth as say Cao Ila which i find more to my liking. Nonetheless it makes for a nice dram and refines my palette further. If you like smokey, heather, vanilla, nuts (but not sweet) then I would recommend Bunnahabhain 12 yo(Reserve). There was also a special edition reserve for Duty Free (airports) which i bought that was very nice too. This one I would also add a teaspoon of spring water to bring the flavours/nose out.

5th June 2014

Made of the finest unicorn tears, this is is one is my go to.

4th June 2014

As my father worked on Islay as a young man, I had a 'heads up' on this particular brand. It really is a wonderfully rich Scotch with abundant peaty aroma and taste. It does n't scald the palate like some other single malts, rather it warmly envelopes you. Pricey but absolute value for money.

3rd June 2014

If people are going to comment on the whisky or matters involving whisky then I really think they should be up to an acceptable standard of education before you accept their views. Really some of the grammar, spelling and script is quite, quite appalling. Please try and up the standards!
Ronald Silvermore.

2nd June 2014

Can't beat this stuff. Pure class. All time favourite.

31st May 2014

nothing to add, for me always be no. 1

26th May 2014

Although a person of modest means, your Lagavulin 16 is the only scotch that I will drink. No more Chevis Regal for me! I am totally ruined for any other scotch. I love the smoky peat taste.

20th May 2014

...and the other way around. Try this with anything on the mellow side of Alice in Chains. Jesus christ....

18th May 2014

Suckling on the maternal teat....Magic!

15th May 2014

Drinking some now. You got it DOWN, Lagavulin makers. I know it's bad for me to have just one more, but just one more. So expensive, but perfection is worth it. I can't afford more than a bottle every once in a while, but maybe that's a good thing. My liver will be the better for it. An explosion of WOW in my mouth with every sip. Thank you.

11th May 2014

I am not very very impressed with this scotch. I like smoke in my whiskey and bought a bottle of Lagavulin 16YO with promise of similarities with Lafraugh. However the Lagavulin is not in any way matched with the Lafraugh. It doesn't taste bad, but there's no strenght to it either.

10th May 2014

I bought a bottle for my son. We tasted it, and it was just beautiful!
Son was so impressed that he had to share it with everyone who visited!
Seriously, I'm afraid I would only share with very close friends who had an appreciation of a good
whiskey!

9th May 2014

I am new to the single malt scene and in my limited knowledge must say this is the best whiskey I've ever had. It's an educational experience this whiskey. Like I said I the title this one is my best yet.

8th May 2014

I have just tasted this and it is truly exceptional. It starts with a beautiful mouth feel and then the complexity is amazing.It is what I am looking for when I want an Islay whiskey. I can hardly wait to have some with good smoked salmon.

3rd May 2014

Anyone who describes this scotch as "ok" knows little about Islay scotch and probably is dumb enough to mix it with soda..

2nd May 2014

Ardbeg has had its moments in recent history, unbeatable 5-6 years ago, for sure. Laphroaig will always be a huge favourite and is as good as its ever been but Lagavulin is in a different league at the moment. Its complex deep, rich and all consuming compared to the Ardbeg, much more 3 dimensional; its finesse and refinement put it apart from the Laphroaig. The most complete whisky you can get at the moment, It's a must try in my book

1st May 2014

This is a reasonable dram but nothing compared to the Ardbegs or Laphroaigs. The much more mellow peatiness of this makes it a good cool-down after a couple of the former whiskies though. It's a fun feeling to have the peatiness of a Laphroaig still lingering in your nose while you sip on one of these. However even that said, I far prefer the Distiller's Edition if getting a Lagavulin--the sweetness makes it a bit more rounded than the rotten driftwood flavor I get from this one. Still I wouldn't turn it down, and it's substantially better than many more expensive whiskies I've tried, slightly better than the similar Talisker 18.

29th April 2014

There is no better islay whisky. The Ardbeg freaks need to take heed.

24th April 2014

Just tasted this. I have tasted some great whiskies, this has to be a favorite in my collection! Magnificent whiskey, for its age and price

15th April 2014

This was my first ever single malt. I remember driving home, thinking "50€ is at the very peak of my financial capabilities, so this better be good and worth the reviews". And I wasn't disappointed. Somewhere I had read that if you choose Lagavulin as your first ever single malt, the rest might never feel that good again. Well, it's absolutely right! Not that there aren't any better whiskies in the world: there probably are. But for a first ever single malt: this is indeed incredibly good! Easy to drink, perfect balance between peat, smoke and sherry. After drinking about 15cl, you still feel that amazing peat after-taste even after 10-15 minutes. Truly special stuff, highly recommended!

4th April 2014

Amazing taste, needs 20 swirls before drinking, get ready to have a totally different Scotch experience.

4th April 2014

This is a fantastic single malt for those looking for something a little different out of their whisky. It does have a strong, almost medicinal smell (iodine is a fitting reference), but don't be put off. The best part is the intense, smoky finish which comes so smoothly to the senses. While not for the faint of heart, this is truly one of the finest drams for those who like a unique experience from their whisky. My favorite single malt to date.

3rd April 2014

Clear alcohol is for rich women on diets. This is a real drink.

29th March 2014

So far the most balanced regular bottling of any distillery I've tried. At its price range nothing else compares to this beautiful dram.

29th March 2014

Have you noticed yours is the only bad review?! this is the best single malt, nay whiskey, period!

25th March 2014

As a Laphroig man i was eagre to taste this .I must say this is very,very nice whiskey.The smoke, peat,Fruity sweetness,oak all shine through really enjoyable taste an overall Excellent whiskey !!!!

14th March 2014

So far my penultimate. And to the ridiculous single bloke commenting below...I hope it is giving you solace. Me? keeping some under my petticoats

7th March 2014

20 years on as a single malt drinker, never tasted anything better as yet. Not for everyone surely, as it takes many years to develop the palate. I used to drink neat but use little ice nowadays. Always keep one at home. Very refined.

5th March 2014

Bought a bottle of this just after Christmas and I'm fairly new to Whisky. Heard a lot of great stuff about it which does NO justice for it. It's not only the best Whisky I've tried, it's one of the best drinks I've tried, Alcoholic or Non-Alcoholic.

Must buy.

5th March 2014

Make no mistake, this is a man's malt. Not one to argue with but one to embrace with sensitivity to maximise the taste enjoyment.
Of course, the fair sex drinks malts too, but I doubt many of them will swap their Highland Park for this beast any time soon. Indeed even some men may well prefer a dram that's a little less in their face.
Fortunately, my favourite tea is Lapsang Souchong. This is the alcoholic (and cold) version with a peaty smokiness that takes you straight to the distillery building.
But that's not all. Uniquely dominant though the peat is, it's beautifully counterbalanced by rich spicy fruit & a reasonable snooze in the sherry barrel.
I can guarantee that this is one malt that, once tasted, you'll never ever forget.
Right, I'm off for a cup of Lapsang. Then again......!

5th March 2014

Each time I have a sip it gets better and better. It's astonishing.

1st March 2014

It is the definition of scotch whiskey to me. So wonderful and beautiful. It's supurb.

23rd February 2014

I taste the edge of the whiskey barrel touching the whiskey. It's so good is amazing. There's a sweetness to it that rolls off your tongue. The smoke and peat is perfectly balanced with the sweetness. It truly is the ultimate scotch whiskey for me.

23rd February 2014

The best period.

23rd February 2014

One of the best Islay whiskies there is.

20th February 2014

Absolutely superb. Just the right balance of peat smoke and fruity complexity. Incredible value for money at the price too.

20th February 2014

How clever of Lagavulin to mature their 'entry level' at 16 years. It subdues the intensity of the peat and allows appreciation of all the other complex flavours that make this such a knock-out Islay. If you are a peat freak then you may find this underwhelming, but if you like a balanced dram then this is for you. A very fine Islay.

17th February 2014

"Cognac of whiskies" - Brian Cox
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HgTPs2_ut8

13th February 2014

It is how it is supposed tot be, pretty close to perfect.
No need for ice or water.

8th February 2014

tried the 12 as a very new entrant to the world of whisky..never had anything like it. made me smile. a lot. very rewarding so had to try the 16. completely different experience. more refined certainly. a lovely smokiness but no peaty fire like the 12.
for me, next bottle is going to be back to the 12 i think. which is handy coz its cheaper. altho i will prob have to try the 16 distillers edition as ive heard its cracking (for 65 odd quid it better be). long live Laga.

1st February 2014

I am in no way a fan of peated or Smokey Whisky. I can't stand Ardbeg, laphroig etc, but with Lagavulin its different, even though its rich, the flavours of the smoke and peat are well balanced on the tongue. This not only makes it drinkable for me, but something really nice. The. First time i tried it was at a Whisky Live tasting even, they recommended having a smoked cheese along with a lagavulin to promte the flavours, and it works!

1st February 2014