Perfection
I had two drinks the other day and it's some of the best top shelf scotch you can get. This stuff never disappoints. It's a bit strong on the alcohol, but it's known for this feature. A little goes a long way. Sipping material..
Jacob C. Jan 22, 2021
Smoky and coastal, but too high price.
I´ve tasted only Lagavulin 16 before, usually I drink peat monsters like Laphroaig or Ardbeg ...or Caol Ila 12, which I wouldn´t call a monster. Maybe Lagavulin 16 was a bit too sophisticated for me, but this release is different.
I think that this belongs to the same category than, for example Caol Ila 12, but as a cask strenght release, with 56,4 ABV, it has more body. Still, Caol Ila 12 doesn´t feel thin with the 43 ABV, in comparison with this release. Biggest difference is that this lacks the characteristic chalky and vinegary ashiness of Caol Ila, something you possibly learn to like over time. But that´s enough about Caol Ila.
Lagavulin 12 is smoky, and especially without added water, a bit oily and sweet. What I like in this, is that it´s not overwhelmingly sweet, as many modern whiskies tend to be. Very, very coastal, without going too much in the details. Even with the 56 ABV, it feels fresh and light, but absolutely not weak, and alcohol doesn´t feel overpowering. Water improves especially nose, after a small experimentation, I found out that teaspoon in a 4cl, was best for my taste. But try yourself, this whisky takes water very well, as you should expect with the cask strenght.
I must say that this is my new favourite, strong, balanced and complex whisky. Nothing dominates too much. I like it more than 16, but that´s the matter of taste. Only because of the high price, I will give it 4 stars. Still, I´m definitely waiting for the 2021 release.
Ahti Valkeapää Oct 6, 2020
