Scotch Whisky - Blended - 2014
International Wine & Spirit Competition
Standard Blends - 2013
The Scotch Whisky Masters (The Spirits Business)
Please enter your details to make it easier for us to help you further.
The legal stuff: not providing your contact details may mean we have to delete your
comments if another member of our community complains about them. Whatever happens though, we’ll never share
your contact details unless you specifically tell us we can.
Please click here for more details.
What a sad surprise. This "new" Black Bottle is totally something else than the one it has been.Those comments from other below are telling how wonderfull it was. Also referring for those awards archieved.We can only guess the real reasons for the change; (cannot have "material" from Islay for same price, try to make more money from the market...). I'm not intrested about Black Bottle anymore. It has been ruined.
31st March 2015
This new whisky blend is still very good for the price.The blend Still has a taste of its own[Fruity/smokey/peaty]like the old one had which makes it stand out at this price range.Good work to keep it at this price.I paid just over £17 for this bottle which is good value for this outstanding & different tasting blend.
6th March 2015
I guess that is where they are going with this new blend. It has very little interesting notes in the flavor and seems pretty blahzey. Bars and pubs will buy it in mass quantities maybe as a mixer but as a dram or on the rocks, I would not bother with it again. The bottle just went under the bar for guests. I will now search out the old green bottle version.
14th January 2015
This is, at best, a mixer. The old one had character and taste.
The old Black Bottle was a superb, competitively priced peat treat, that (whilst not being quite as well integrated) rivaled Johnnie Walker Black due to its fantastic price and accessibility. I enjoyed many a bottle, and still have one as a keep safe (purchased for £11.97 from Tesco as they were clearing their shelves). This new version, in a distinctive black bottle (as opposed to the previous version's green bottle) is supposed to mirror the original blend developed in 1879. Whether this is true or just a bit of nostalgic marketing who knows, but I can recommend the whisky. It has a rather ridiculously dark amber colour (even more so than the Johnnie Walker ranges) and the caramel influences (that tannin taste) is obvious. However, despite the lack of peat (which is, despite a subtle whiff, virtually non-existent) this is a superbly well rounded whisky with a bit fruity taste, herbs on the nose, toffee and caramel on the palate, a great mouth feel and a rich, almost chocolatey finish. There are undoubtedly reasons why Black Bottle has changed (industry and economic reasons) I'm sorry to say, and the heavy addition of caramel is not a good start. But once you look beyond that and accept that the old whisky has gone (unfortunately) you're still left with a whisky that is incredibly well crafted and far better value than anything else in its price range. For just £2 less you could be drinking Scottish Leader! This is like a well honed single malt compared to that! So for the naysayers, embrace change (as I have done) and enjoy this splendid dram. The result of the re-launch could of been so much worse!
21st November 2014
The peat of Islay mixed with cereal of speyside is gone. Sad. Not bad, but not nearly as good as teh previous version.
17th October 2014
The bold peaty character of an Islay which represented the previous Black Bottle is gone in this new version.
15th October 2014
Maybe if Black Bottle is new to you, you could be forgiven for thinking this is OK but to me it is a disgrace. Haven't seen Black Bottle on the shelves for a while now so was delighted to find this while out shopping today - but what a let-down. Black Bottle was always my blend of choice when fund were too low to afford Ardbeg (which, let's face it is most of the time at current pricing). Where is 'the heart of Islay'? I won't be buying this again. Big mistake messrs Graham.
12th October 2014
Most of the negative reviews here seem disappointed at how this new BB is different from the old. (I never had the old one, so am happily unburdened by such luggage...) I think that misses the point that this is an excellent blended whisky, at a price point that offers superb value. I'm not normally much of a fan of blended Scotch, I only came across this by accident when doing my weekly grocery shop, and boy am I glad I picked up a bottle! I'll go back tomorrow and get a case, before they discontinue it (my supermarket, that is - they have a bad habit of doing that, just as I discover something I like).
22nd June 2014
A good Whisky doesn't have a screw cap !!.... However I could be wrong.Well I am with this one. Outstanding for Scotch at this price.
14th June 2014
I think the people running this down have approached it the wrong way. This is not a changed or improved Black bottle but a completely new whisky. As someone else has said it is as good as double black and £13 cheaper. As soon as they get more in I shall order a half dozen more.
2nd June 2014
Mr Gordon BellI have tried many brands of whisky and have enjoyed most of them! However, the one whisky I keep coming back to, when I can get it (I live in deepest - darkest Staffordshire...), is Graham's Black Bottle. I am not alone in appreciating this fine blend, as I have encouraged many friends and collegues to sample frequently.... and they all agree with me, this truly is a very good, high quality blended whisky. Indeed my father, John Bell (butcher of this parish), won runner's up prize in a competition run by the distillery and won 6 very fine tumblers engraved with the whisky's label. My father loved Black Bottle and instilled into me this love and appreciation of probably the most consistently good blends on the market. I highly recommend this blend, as it is very easy to enjoy. It is not harsh on the throat and fills the mouth with a fabulous mixture of peaty, smokey, fruity, sweetness - a joy to enjoy! So do yourself a flavour...I mean favour and buy a bottle today, your tongue will thank you for it! By the way - the best way to enjoy this whisky, or any other blend for that matter, is to add a splash of water. But don't drown it! The master blender of any distillery would have your guts for garters if he saw you or anybody else, diluting away all his hard work by putting too much H 2 O in his skillfully put together work of art!1st April 2010
31st May 2014
Ach!!!! Yeh are all full o' wind an' pish!!!!!I thought perfection could not be improved upon. But I have to admit, I was wrong! The "new" Black Bottle is better for going back to its roots and re-introducing Gordon Graham's original blend. The old blend was - sorry - is very good if you are lucky enough to find it! But with the return to its roots this blend even beats that!Graham's original blend is sweet, smooth, flavoursome, smoky, spicy. In one word - excellent!! Buy with confidence my friends, you will not be disappointed! You will enjoy a very, very fine blend made by really skilled craftsmen. So if you have any doubts after reading the negative comments. Take a look at the very first review. - MY review!You will see I do have real soft spot for this whisky but now this has returned to its heritage they have really struck gold. Disappointing - my arse! Won't finish this bottle - nonsense! Won't buy again - well mate that's your loss and all the more for me to enjoy!My advice - buy a bottle and make up your own mind! This is still a GREAT whisky! Don't let anybody put you off.
18th May 2014
The old blend was one of the greats, unfortunately this new blend is very poor and bears absolutely no resemblance to it's predecessor. Why they couldn't release this under a different name and keep the old blend is beyond me - for example, how many types of Famous Grouse are available now!?! Won't be buying this again unless they revert back to their previous blend. A real shame.
17th May 2014
Basically only good to mix with. It no longer stands alone unless you are cleaning the bar top. Sad, it was a distinctive blend worthy of praise. Might as well buy Crown Royal and save the money.
9th May 2014
well the marketing team have really sorted this once fine whisky out new shape of bottle / colour of contents but most of all its joined the realms of cooking
1st May 2014
This stuff tastes like leftovers from dozens of Speyside whisky's , not harmonious at all, I remember this used to taste of wonderful Islay malts and a good intro to that islands style, now it's just a bargain basement style blend at a semi premium price.
28th April 2014
Been drinking and enjoyed this brand for some years now. This relaunch has completely changed the character of the whisky. Not for me now I'm afraid.
19th April 2014
A return to the past. Why? Not everything was better in the olden days. I'll have to find another drink.
14th April 2014
I was more than suprised trying this scotch whisky.It was full offruity taste, and spicy and peaty.Heard a lot of bad rep. from the previous bottling that ruined some feedback.It cost about 19 euros , it isn't cheap for whay you get.Now its my favorite islay scotch whisky.I would choose this ower Johnny Walker Double Black any time even if its a lot spicier and less refined.Thanks, KaaBee.
28th February 2014