Distillers' Single Malts 12 years and under - 2014
International Spirits Challenge
Scotch Single Malt - Island - 2014
International Wine & Spirit Competition
Highlands & Islands up to 12yo - 2013
The Scotch Whisky Masters (The Spirits Business)
Please enter your details to make it easier for us to help you further.
Whilst i can see that this whisky has a certain finesse about it, i'm not a fan of it's taste profile. I find it too bland, and lacking in a good sweetness and 'oomph!'. It's vibes are cold and not heartwarming. It's smokiness reminds me of cheap whisky like Teachers. Not overly impressed with this one, although i do find that adding some water DOES significantly improve the taste and add some creamy warmth to it.
19th November 2014
it is aromatic, interesting and quite complex. some of the notes were not for me although a good value dram
16th November 2014
I'm glad i paid no more than £26 for a bottle of this, cos it ain't worth much more. I b ought it based upon the many good reviews but have to say that whilst i find it a very delicate Whisky, that i also feel that the flavours are very 'muted'. Ralfy on 'u tube', scored this presentation lower than the original one, blamed it on chill filtering and added colouring, to make this current presentation more 'trendy'. I gotta say i know where he's coming from, and feel this Whisky is somehow missing that big expression of flavours. I'll report back later on, but for now it's a decent whiskey that is sweet and smoky, but also very crisp. Could do with more overall warmth.
9th November 2014
I've enjoyed the flavor of this scotch. I prefer smoky, peaty scotches and this one (as someone mentioned earlier) is a really good scotch for the price. Warm, smoky, comforting all around!
24th October 2014
A go-to brand. Inexpensive but nice. Easy to drink, quite smooth for a 12 year old.
23rd October 2014
Pretty new to single malts and haven't tried that many. Also, I'm still trying to build a career and am not enormously flush. So I tend to pitch my tent next to the £20-30/bottle range in Morrison's, and have tried the likes of Glenmorangie 10, Aberlour 10, Glenlivet 12, Ledaig (nice young whisky) All of the above are clearly superior to the cheap, blended rubbish but the HP 12 is the nicest I've tried so far. A revelation!
19th October 2014
great 'all rounder' touches of spice, citrus and a hint of smoke on the finish. A main stay of the collection
11th October 2014
Never met a whisky drinker who didn't like HP. In it's price range, you will not find a better dram balancing sweet, smoke & salt at the same time. It's a class act.
29th September 2014
Like the review "Don't Forget Old Friends" of Sept.12, 2014, I too, have come back to Highland Park 12. Highland Park was the first Scotch that I really liked (loved). But it became my quest to try the best of the best from all the regions of Scotch, trying to see if there was one that grabbed me . .. one that I would fall in love with and keep buying as my favorite dram, no matter the price. I love the Islays with their peat and smoke; love the sherried malts with their sweetness (but must have a little peat and smoke with that sweetness). There are some outstanding examples of these flavours but the very best example of all these characteristics put together is Highland Park 12. I have spent (and wasted) big bucks on single malts, while HP still remains very affordable. So I came back . . . to stay! It is truly the malt that I love above all the rest . .. even the much higher priced Islays. I too, see no need to search any further. Highland Park 12. A near perfect Scotch Whisky!
22nd September 2014
This the best value HP as the 18 and 21 years olds are now ridiculously overpriced.
It has a dry finish that comes as a surprise as the arrival is sweet Sherry. There is just the right amount of peat and smoke for my taste, but Islay peatheads will find it lacking. I hope HP can maintain quality that has been variable in the recent past. At its best it is a great dram from Orkney.
21st September 2014
For a long time a staple in my whisky cabinet, this HP is currently £25 on offer in my local supermarket and often can be found at or around this price. Given its perfect balance of heather honey sweetness and subtle wiff of something between smoke and the salty sea that comes on the finish, along with a clean smooth feel on the throat (as opposed to so many harsh , spicy whiskies that I have in my collection at 3 or 4 times the price of this), I defy anyone to suggest a better malt for the money.
I was sold by the smoky flavor notes but the deal-breaker for me was the "aromatic peat". No big deal though, this is how we find our way through the wonderful land of whisky. So many of them out there, so little time.
16th September 2014
HP12 was the whiskey that opened up the world of single Malts to me some 5 years ago. When I first tried it, in a moment I realized that all of the chivas, jw black, and glenlivet that I had once considered good fell into a separate category of sub par whiskey. Immediately hooked, I have, over the years, sampled most of the tried and true classics, finding my own personal palate at home best with the peat, smoke, brine of Malts like lagavulin 16, Talisker 10, and Ardbeg oogie. After years of always trying something new, I just bought a bottle of 2014 hp12, only to realize how much I have missed this old friend. Perfectly balanced in ever way, setting itself above all others except for the lag and the Talisker, which are higher priced and hard to beat in their class. Great whiskey in every way.
Per Michael Jackson:
The Greatest all-rounder in the wold of malt whisky. Definitely in an island style, but combining all the elements of a classic single malt: smokiness, with its own heather-honey acen); maltiness; smoothness; depth, roundness and fullness of flavour; and length of finish - lovely any time.
12th September 2014
have to admit after reading the reviews I was looking forward to this one but was a bit disappointed. not all bad bad just a bit too burnie for me
11th September 2014
This is better than I expected for the price. It has a smooth and sweet, sort of butterscotchy body that at first struck me as being like a good blend, but after the first impression, a lot more detail emerged. It is particularly interesting to see how this whisky changes as it sits in your mouth: At first the sweetness from the sherry is most dominant, from which the smoke builds and sweetness fades into a sort of fruity spice, finally finishing with a lingering, dry smoke. Definitely satisfying, and not too expensive.
6th September 2014
I was used to keep a bottle of cheapy crappy whisky in the cabinet to make the better bottles last a little longer. Now it's this HP12 doing this job nicely except the price.
1st September 2014
4th August 2014
Why do you drink scotch whisky? If it is for the taste, then you cannot find a better TASTING on the planet . . . PERIOD. I have been searching for the ultimate, illusive, perfect scotch . . . from Islay, the Highlands, the lowlands . . thinking I needed to spend big to find it . .. not so. There just is no better tasting scotch out there. It has it all; peat, smoke, sweetness. I just can't find a better scotch, so I am going to stop looking. Highland Park 12.
28th July 2014
I can't imagine a better 12 year whisky. I have had them all. I am a long established Scotch drinker that has drank a huge variety of whisky.This seems to be the most well rounded of the less expensive whiskies that I drink. I don't understand any of the negatitive reviews. I can hardly wait to open my bottle of 30 year Highland Park. But in the meantime, thank you for Highland Park 12 year!
17th July 2014
Well balanced single malt. I like the strong fruity smell and the taste of sweetness.Very good whisky! Good to keep one always if you have a collection.
20th June 2014
If your a fan of peaty whisky then this is for you, lovely intense flavour, fantastic nose.
For the price this packs
well above its weight in my
opinion! I recently tried the 18yr and that was stunning, I'll be getting a bottle for special occasions, however the 12yr is a worthy everyday replacement.
28th May 2014
I bought this Whisky many years ago after it was recommended to Me as being A Great Malt at a sensible price.I now buy this every time i want to treat myself.It has a taste which to Me is superb,smoke & peat with spicy sweetness later.I now always recommend this one to friends & workmates and they all later agree how good it is.Highland Park is One of the Best Malts.
23rd May 2014
Great! I am new to scotch but this has become my go-to after i tried many others. Warming on a cold day. Balance is just right. Perfect amount of smoke and fruit. Very smooth.
13th May 2014
I'm new to Whisky but have tried quite a few lately and have started to understand what the fuss is about. This has a nice delicate smoke to it, not as powerful as an Ardbeg 10 but this does not detract, very nice introduction to smoky malts.
5th May 2014
Basically the distillery had changed its focus from the 12 year old to the more profitable older aged malts. Last two years this has been awful, steer clear, is terrible how this whisky has declined.
28th April 2014
Just opened a bottle, great for a 12 year old, has to be favourite 12.
11th April 2014
In the last 4 years I must have drank about 10 bottles of this whiskey. This is one of my all time favorites and you will (most probably) not be disappointed either. I've been recommending this particular whiskey to all my friends since and they're all loving it.
However, the last bottle I bought somewhere in 2013 was not good at all. At first I thought it was me, but drinking a few more glasses during the week I became more and more convinced there was actually something wrong with the whiskey. After reading up on it in Jim Murray's Whiskey Bible of 2013 - giving it a shocking 70-score only - ánd tasting a bottle I gave to a friend a year earlier, it was 100% confirmed that something went wrong with the whiskey that year.
Because of this I have not bought one again since. Now a year has passed and I will try one again and hope it will be back to the quality it used to be. If it is, you simply cannot miss this one. Really.
10th April 2014
The nose hinted at oak, heather, and smokey fire. Upon entry, it had an astringent quality with a light sweetness... kind of like cough syrup. This ultimately faded into a smoke bomb though with a malty sweetness in the background. I didn't care for it as it was and a splash of water didn't help. However, and I know it may be sacrilege to some, a 50/50 mix with 18 yo Glenmorangie REALLY turned into a phenomenal dram! Honestly! It toned down the smokieness and embraced a lot of the finer heather grilled fruit notes.
28th March 2014
There's something about Highland Park 12 that I really enjoy. Smooth, smoky, classy tasting whisky for the price. Unlike the other reviewer below, I prefer this over The Macallan 12 and Glenmorangie. This is my favorite malt for the price.
25th March 2014
To know what to avoid next. I will not but more of this as for the price there is better offerings. Too much watered down makes this average whisky
22nd March 2014
Was interested to try this whiskey hearing it as the best all rounder, and I bought a miniature bottle incase it wasn't my cup of tea.
It was a very nice scotch, almost as if tasting scotch for the first time, very sweet and smokey with water added, but I was still expecting something more having heard about it's complexity.
Think i'll splash out on the 18 year old ins tread, but for what's it in. A perfect evening whiskey, but don't expect to be blown away.
13th March 2014
But watered down too much, makes no better than most average whiskys
12th March 2014
I bought a bottle yesterday, and tried it side by side with Macallan and Glenmorangie. I have to say that Highland Park is absolutely a no-no for me. I am glad that many people love it, but it is simply not my cup of tea. Glenmorangie is my top choice for a single malt whisky.
10th March 2014
very very very goooooood
3rd March 2014
the way its described is perfect but not for me but still very nice in its own way. my taste is the balvenie doublewood
2nd March 2014
This was way better than I expected. Gentle smoke and peat with some great pepper. There is underlying sweetness that comes later in the mouthful as you savor it. This is a smooth dram that I will keep in my cabinet as a regular.
20th February 2014
I'm a repeat buyer of HP 12. This whisky has definitely earned it's place among the standard rotating stock of my liquor cabinet. It is exceptionally balanced, embracing all the sweetness and fruitiness of a Speyside or Lowland malt with just the right amount of gentle peaty smokiness and island complexity needed to distinguish it from its competitors, and for the price this is quite a good deal indeed. In this case the smokiness and general character of this malt is definitely of a warming campfire/fireside variety rather than the love-it-or-leave-it iodine/medicinal peat of Islay. If you are seeking an excellent balanced scotch whisky at a modest price point, this one is very hard to beat.
14th February 2014
Rating within class and price range.
7th February 2014
Touches most every flavor profile of scotch regions in some way or another. I like it straight or with a 1/2 tsp of water in a skinny dram, but it will take more (if you like to moderate the slight alcohol bite and wood smoke) without wrecking it, actually bringing a sweet and floral character to the front; very versatile at 43%. If you've been interested in the Bunnahabhain Toiteach but shudder at the price, the Toiteach with a tiny splash is very similar to this HP12, excepting the slightly briny note of the Bunna.
HP labels are hard to see through the bottle but appears to be batch L0263R L4 22/07 10:46.
This is a great entry level whisky and fairly smooth for something made in as harsh surroundings as Orkney. It has a bit of body and a low smokey, spicy finish that lasts nicely.
Great value and of course it goes without saying there are better bottles about, but many will cost you more. If you like this, it will be a nice stepping stone to some of the more characteristic island whiskies.
17th January 2014
Usually sticking to the common blends, this malt was a gift, unfortuneately my pension does not run to be able to afford this 12 but I would highly recommend it.
First time trying HP 12 and was not disappointed in any way. If your reading these reviews don't bother listening to the negative comments. This scotch has a smooth taste to start and warm enjoyable aftertaste. Highly recommend.
12th January 2014
After reading the reviews, I thought I'd give this a try. Nothing worth shouting about. Average at best. Stick to Glenfarclas.
27th December 2013
I'm new to the world of scotch whisky, but having tried 9 fairly different ones from Ardbeg to Old Pulteney, Dalmore to Glenlivet, I'm trying to be as diverse as possible. This one is my favorite so far. As promised, this beautiful drink has a bit of everything: peat, sweet, fruitiness, and a lingering finish.
22nd December 2013
Nothing else to be said
20th December 2013
I have bought a lot of whisky from MoM, but this one I can get in my local liquor store (US resident). If you take your whisky thrill and divide it by your cost, I doubt you'll find many better buys. I have tasted many better whiskies, but they are invariably significantly more expensive. If this cost $200 (US), I probably give this an 8 or 9 overall, but at under $50, it's an absolute 10!
15th December 2013
I don't know much, but I know I'm glad I bought this.
24th November 2013
You know those conversations you sometimes have at the liquor store - those one offs where you and someone exchange some experiences and recommendations, and maybe you try something different? Well, the wife and I were shopping and had a pleasant one of those, and I was searching for my old favorite (Johnny Green) but was disappointed that it was out of stock - and then as she and I were discussing alternatives, an older gentleman suggested we give this bottle a try.
I was not disappointed. My first sip of this was harsh, but then, I'm the kind of nut who likes a Scotch that doesn't need ice - there are some of those out there. This isn't one of them however - and in fact, never have I tasted a Scotch before this one that changes it's stripes so completely with the simple addition of some ice. The taste of this is magnificent. It's very well rounded, and the honey and smoke are there - but the peat didn't stand up and scream - it was there, but subdued by the sweet overtones and rich flavors. The ice was everything to this, and once added, it ascended into heaven.
Definitely a pleasant bottle - and not a bad price either. Here in the US it's about $45, but well worth it.
23rd November 2013
After trying the HP 15, I decided to pick up a bottle of the 12. I was a bit surprised by how distinct the two were (I'm not much of a whiskey drinker....). The 12 is well described at the top of the page as sweet, honey-like with a hint of wood shavings, likely from years in a sherry cask. I think it would pair very well with dark chocolate cake or a nice cigar. I find it more subtle and shorter on the palate than the 15, which is more complex and lasting in flavour evolution. Overall, I prefer the 15 but the 12 definitely has its merits. I think I will now save the 15 for special occasions and have the 12 as a reliable standby.
16th November 2013
This is a great whisky. If I had to recomend one it would be this.Its for men not boys.
15th November 2013
There is something really enjoyable about this stuff. I'll agree with some of the negative reviews that the nose, at first, is a little off (like kerosene and low tide) but this bottle really grew on me. My personal description would be campfire on the beach. Warm and nautical. I think I found my go-to single malt. I've paid double or triple the price for bottles I've thought much less of. That being said, this is only my 5th single malt that I've tried so take my opinion for what it's worth.
13th November 2013
I am no great whisky expert but this one I really like excellent value for money
7th November 2013
I'm missing something with this. Recommended by many and tried many times by me. I don't think I'd buy a bottle of this again. Its a nice enough whiskey but much better around at the same price.... Jason Breen
1st November 2013
This is one amazing whisky. For those of you who rate it low, I dare you to find something better for under $50 U.S.
13th October 2013
I have never been a whisky drinker, but have been drawn more towards it recently. After sampling a couple of flights at a local pub, just to get a taste, I then went out and bought my first bottle - A Highland Park - and am now good and truly hooked. This bottle has lit a fire in my soul, and I can't believe I've been passing up on it for so long. I will defer on the rating, because I have so little baseline for comparison, but I will say that this stuff is simply delicious.
1st October 2013
This came highly recommended and I was disappointed. Unpleasant chemical after taste, not dissimilar to inhaling petrol. I'm more of a lighter whisky fan but I gave this away to a greatful friend. Not to my taste.
21st September 2013
I used to like this whisky, but the last bottle I bought... Couldn't agree more with Jim Murray. I weep for Highland Park distillery
8th August 2013
just got my new bottle today frist time from MoM GREAT SERVICE just about to crack in to my next 2 bottles :) this dram is better than the last time and long may it last.
15th July 2013
should be in every pub in ireland for gods sake and mine
12th July 2013
I hoped the folk at HP would check the batch and maybe concur to some degree so I could purchase another bottle with confidence & find out what everyone else seems to say, but as they didn't do this and gave me hardly any feedback other than thanking me for my letter and saying maybe I was more sensitive to it than most, I wont be risking it i'm afraid when there's so many other scotch's I know I like and yet to try. BTW soda? wash your mouth out lol
5th June 2013
Not sure what the reviewer above was expecting the folk at Highland Park to do with his feedback, but assuming they haven't tearfully flushed it all away, I highly recommend it. Very tasty, rich and smooth. Just keep it away from the soda.
31st May 2013
I recently bought a bottle of this (in Mar 2013) and to say im disappointed after reading all the good reviews is an understatement. its basically fit only for giving to guests who don't know what decent whisky is to use with mixers (which is what i'll be doing with it). I checked in the whisky bible after tasting it and wasn't at all surprised to find that the author says the same thing about the 2012 release. I contacted highland park with my thoughts and after an initial pretence of being interested in my feedback didn't do much else. I wont be risking any more of my cash on HP scotch
29th May 2013
An outstanding whisky that I keep buying over and over.
Has a little bit of everything, but not too much of anything.
8th April 2013
Finished off the bottle in the Kinlochbervie Hotel bar. I have been hooked since. An incredibly well rounded dram that i have great pleasure introducing to my friends. Salivating as i write this.
11th March 2013
Have tasted a few hundred dollar (State side here) options, but nothing extravagant and I am a Scotch novice overall. I did much research before buying my first full bottle. This Highland Park 12 year was my choice, and I have to say, for the money I couldn't imagine doing better. Balanced sweat and smokey flavored with the freshness of greens.. along with jus the right amount of bite. Love it.
10th March 2013
Sweet (but not cloying), floral, dry, a little peaty - this one really has everything in one package.
7th February 2013
just wonderful fav at the moment and for a long time to come
21st January 2013
I was searching around for a good 12-year under $40 or so and this one came up. Really like this and the smoky finish. Tried this next to a Glenlivet 12 and I don't think I'll ever buy the Glenlivet again
11th January 2013
At first I was a little concerned by the nose; it is quite heavy with the manuka honey, with that bitter beeswax and buttery toast that I am usually not a fan of. But give it a little while to develop - it doesn't take very long and you get fresh fruity subtleties like apple peels and citrus leaf, alongside cream and baked orange with the peel on. It becomes more speyside-y with time with more powerful notes from red berries and more creamy notes. The palate, which to some is the most important bit, is incredible, INCREDIBLE, nuts, oranges, slight peat, light spice, wild botanicals like heather and juniper, there is buttery toast, creamy brown sugar and slight juiciness. The balance is splendid, just splendid. on the finish there is a lovely coating of oranges, vanilla toffee, fudge, lovely light smokiness which I have no idea how they achieved. Man this is good. Highly recommended, ESPECIALLY AT £25?!?!?!??!!?!?
9th January 2013
I had heard great reports from a work colleague on HP 12 and decided to buy for Christmas as a treat.I am new to single malt whisky and can say this HP12 is a beautiful tasting dram and I was not disappointed.Since buying this I have been fortunate over the past week to try out a few more drams including Glenfiddich 15 yo Solera, Glenlivet 12 yo and a Laphroaig Quarter cask.They were all fine tasting in my palate, but HP12 is going to be a regular purchase as for me it was smoother and more enjoyable to drink than the others.Its a whisky that tastes far more luxurious the £25 I paid for it.Great value.
2nd January 2013
1st January 2013
I really enjoy the highland park 12yo it's perfectly balanced and you get everything you would expect. Sweet, little peaty working together with dry and sweet fruits and nut flavors and then medium dry what a lovely whisky I always go back to this lovely whisky can't get enough. So far I've tried the glenmorangie, aberlour, glenlivet, talisker and Laphroaig and they don't seem to satisfy my palate like the highland park. Great whisky keep up the good work!!!
Should be called the Orkney Islands but never the orkneys!
20th December 2012
Love the orkneys, I love the peat and honey combo best I have tried
16th December 2012
This is a nice rounded single malt but seems to lack the depth and complexity of other single malts. This is very noticeable when compared to a 10 year old Glengoyne which is far more complex and just as smooth. So much more depth than the HP12...Still good value though.
9th December 2012
This is a fine whisky. To me, it tasted somewhat like a Speyside with a mild peat under it. The peat flavor is not overpowering as in Lagvulin or Laphroig and lets the other flavors shine through. Karl
19th September 2012
If you just start your malt journey, or even if you are a old runner on the malt trail, there is no way you are not gonna like this.
An amazing whiskey. way better then Glenlivet 12, Glenffidich 12, Macallan 12...etc and it's not a matter of taste, it is way better "."
23rd August 2012
My palate cannot appreciate these hugely expensive whiskies and this to me is the perfect balance between taste and cost. It tastes a hell of a lot more expensive than it actually is - a perfect compromise.
2nd August 2012
.. did mention manuka honey. Makes me wonder why they missed a statement on "it's intrinsic quality".
4th July 2012
.. did not mention peat?
For my money, the Highland Park 12 is one of the best entry-level whiskies available. Mild smokiness, a touch of honey, a savoury finish - it's got a bit of everything. Great value for money.
2nd July 2012
This is one of the best entry-level whiskies, and represents among the best value for money as well. Great balance of subtle peat and honey sweetness, but lacks that little bit extra that the 18 year-old provides.
22nd June 2012
I was not too sure at first taste, or second, or third, to be honest. The main problem was the peat which is very Bunnahabhain like. But it is a grower and now I look forward to a dram. It's fragrant, then dry, then goes to sweet. Big taste, lovely.
21st June 2012
Met a guy just back from Scotland, after picking up one bottle he came back and picked up a second bottle of Highland Park in the same visit to our local store. I asked what was so special about this brand, he told me about his trip and his tasting, I've been hooked ever since, absolutely love it.
24th May 2012
Fragrant smoke with a soft kerosene, sweety lacquer and wood, moderate spirit and malt, which's leftovers prevail in modest aftertaste. Definitely better than Johnnie Walker Black, but maybe a little bit lower than Green Label. Worth trying, anyway.
3rd May 2012
1st April 2012
And they will if my plans for world domination come to fruition!
10th March 2012
While touring Scotland in 2005 we stopped in Edinburgh before heading for London. There I had my first Scotch tasting. I tried several from Laphroig through Highland Park to Glen Morangie and Jura. I kept coming back to Highland Park. I had no previous knowledge of single malts and I just liked this one so I bought a bottle (overpriced with the VAT). Only when I got back to the States did I discover that, apparently, I know a good thing when I find it. It's still my favorite after trying a few others.
25th February 2012
my favourite malt by far and i;v tried a few, delicious,! worth 5*
James Rodger Smart esq,
2nd November 2011
Expected a lot less, affordable and by far the most delicious for the price, hell any price, everything is so balanced. Sweet then dry. Just amazing!
23rd September 2010
Another one that could easily become a staple in someone's cabinet (if not mine). This is a very refreshing dram - one that could easily be enjoyed after sweating and working in the yard. If there was ever a Scotch suitable for summer afternoon enjoyment, this is it. Sweet notes on entry and on finish - the longer you let the finish linger, the sweeter it becomes. Nougat, Caramel, almost a candy bar in a bottle after a minute or so from the last sip. Wonderful Stuff!
20th May 2010
This is the relatively new expression and redesigned bottle from HP. It was remarked in several reviews that perhaps the original 12 yo was just beginning to tire - or maybe tastes change! This new offering is certainly more subtle, slightly less smokey and just a tad sweeter. It does not lose it's Island character and remains one of the great Single Malts. Unlike the whisky however the new packaging and bottle ARE an aquired taste!
16th December 2009